In
2007, the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood stated that its
vision was based on efforts and the need to empower
women so they might acquire rights in the public
sphere that do not conflict with society’s basic
values.
The statement also referred to the
“dominating negative social view regarding women” and
the need to change it by making society fully aware of
women’s rights beyond the right to education, which is
widely accepted in Egyptian society.
Two years after this stated vision of
gender equality, however, and 85 years after
schoolteacher Hassan al Banna founded the Brotherhood
in Egypt in 1924, the current status and role of women
in the Muslim Brotherhood’s organisational structure
remains lacking.
The Muslim Brotherhood’s first women’s
division, the Muslim Sisters Group, was created in
1932. Since then, women activists have been at the
forefront of the social and political struggle of the
Muslim Brotherhood movement in Egypt, which seeks to
establish a democratic political system in the country
with an Islamic frame of reference.
Women activists advocating for an
Islamic political system through the Brotherhood
believe that Islam brought justice to women. Their
lack of equal rights presently, they insist, has to do
more with the cultural, political and social realities
in which their movement functions than with the
movement itself.
Still, more and more female members of
the Muslim Brotherhood are becoming restless about the
lack of representation and are seeking ways to
increase their numbers in senior positions in the
movement itself and, in time, to participate more in
the country’s politics. Primarily, these women want a
formal consultative position in the Muslim Brotherhood
hierarchy.
Fortunately for the Sisters, some of
the leading figures in this group of Brotherhood women
are daughters and wives of senior Brotherhood leaders.
The daughters of higher-ranking
members like Khayrat al-Shater and Essam al-Erayan,
for example, are active Sisters. The first of the
Brotherhood’s female political candidates, Jihan al-Halafawi,
is the wife of Ibrahim al-Zaafarani, a senior member
of the Alexandria chapter of the Muslim Brotherhood.
Due to these connections, women are making their
voices heard despite the lack of an institutionalised
mechanism to consult women at the higher levels of
power.
Furthermore, a growing number of men
in the Brotherhood are now convinced that the current
status of women inside the Muslim Brotherhood is a
“weak point” that needs to be seriously addressed. The
Brotherhood is routinely criticised for its position
on women’s issues, especially since it presents itself
as liberal with regard to politics yet is perceived as
conservative when it comes to women’s issues. The
majority of this pro-women group occupies mid-level
positions in the movement and is calling for increased
women’s leadership within the organisation, as well as
a greater number of female Muslim Brotherhood
candidates in national elections.
Many refer to this redefining of
women’s roles within the movement as a “rebellion of
the Sisters”. But members of the Brotherhood consider
this call for greater women’s participation normal as
the movement evolves over time to accommodate a
dynamic constituency and changing political and social
factors.
While these women activists have
genuine grievances and demand change, they are not
willing to sacrifice the movement’s unity and cohesion
to obtain increased representation in the Muslim
Brotherhood and among political candidates. Many of
them strongly feel that it is only a matter of time
before they gain these rights. Their institutional
loyalties and belief that change is possible, albeit
gradually, shape their call for action.
And their calls are being heard. In
Egypt’s 2000 parliamentary elections, the Muslim
Brotherhood nominated a female candidate, Jihan al-Halafawi,
for the first time – mostly due to pressures exerted
by many of the Sisters. Although the government
eventually ensured her defeat (for being a Brotherhood
candidate, not for gender reasons) by rigging the
vote, harassing her supporters and arresting her
husband and campaign manager, Al-Halafawi had a strong
backing from the public. And while neither of the two
women candidates (including Makarem al-Deeri in 2005)
nominated by the Muslim Brotherhood have been elected
thus far, their popularity and support still set an
important precedent.
A conservative culture in the
Brotherhood, coupled with an oppressive
socio-political context – which the movement sometimes
appears to mirror – is why women in the Brotherhood
fail to acquire adequate representation reflective of
their contribution to the movement’s political
struggle.
Integrating women in the Brotherhood’s
organisational structure will help alter the
perception that it is as patriarchal and undemocratic
as the regime it challenges. It will also give
recognition to the central role played by women in the
movement’s social and political struggles.
The question now is whether the
emergence of a young generation of activists – men and
women alike – will ultimately generate a new political
force which could prove crucial to the Muslim
Brotherhood as a whole, indirectly affecting the
social and political culture in Egypt.