|
19 January 2010
The media punditry, corn-fed on conventional
wisdom, are all atwitter about the looming Democratic
debacle in Massachusetts, saying that win or lose, the
poor showing by the Democratic candidate for the late
Sen. Edward Kennedy’s seat, state Attorney General
Martha Coakley, means Democrats in Congress should
abandon plans to push through a House-Senate
compromise health bill, and instead just go with the
Senate’s version of health “reform” legislation, thus
circumventing a certain Republican filibuster attempt. The Senate bill, remember, is the dreadful health
bill version that outlaws abortion coverage for anyone
getting subsidized insurance, and that taxes the hell
out of health insurance benefits that are the mainstay
of many middle-income and working-class families, not
to mention mandating that people with low incomes
spend significant assets they don’t have to buy lousy
insurance they may not want or need. As bad as the
House version is, the Senate bill is even worse. It is a crummy bill, cobbled together from bits and
pieces of self-serving elements submitted by health
industry lobbyists, who have spent the last year
swarming over the Senate like ants and maggots over a
fetid, unrecognizeable lump of roadkill. The call for the House to adopt the Senate plan, so
as to avoid a filibuster, is advice that would doom
the Democrats in 2010. While that might be a good
thing, given the sorry excuse for an alternative to
the Republicans that the Democrats have become, I
would argue that the time is right for the small rump
of Democrats who are still progressives to take a
stand. They have the power to drive a stake through the
corporatists who run the Democratic Party, and who
have been working assiduously for decades to neuter
the party and especially its progressives caucus. If
progressive members of the House simply refuse to vote
for the Senate version of the health bill, it cannot
go forward. The reason President Barack Obama’s health plan,
the president’s and the Democratic Party’s support
have all cratered even in that most emblematic
Democratic state of Massachusetts is not that
Republicans are resurgent. It is not even that
unaffiliated voters have turned from Obama, though
certainly some have. It’s that Democrats have become
disgusted with the man they turned out for so
enthusiastically in November 2008, with his "plan" for
health "reform," and with the party that they gave
such a resounding victory to in Congress that same
election and in 2006. Democratic voters--especially liberal
Democrats--are rightly feeling punked. Even if they
are voting in Massachusetts, they are not doing it
with any enthusiasm, and aren’t hustling their friends
and coworkers to vote along with them. And the Obama/Democrat health care reform sellout
is only one of their complaints. There is also the
Obama cave-in to Wall Street, and his enormous
escalation of the Afghanistan War, his failure to
restore Constitutional government, and his wishy-washy
efforts on climate change. It’s funny to recall that a year ago, it was common
to hear pundits pronouncing the death of the
Republican Party. Now, it appears that it is actually
the Democratic Party that is headed for history’s
dumpster--with President Obama and the party’s hack
leadership in Congress in the driver’s seat of the
careening truck. Coakley was true to form as the party’s
standard-bearer in this collapse. Even as her
candidacy was heading for the rocks, instead of
campaigning hard for the state’s liberal base, she
headed off on January 12, just a week ahead of the
special election, to pander to lobbyists from the
health industry and to collect hundreds of thousands
of dollars in legal bribes from them. No wonder her
base is deserting her or just staying home! Hell, if I were in Massachusetts, I’d vote for
Coakley’s GOP opponent, Scott Brown. The former
Cosmopolitan centerfold model may be just a
buffer version of former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt
Romney, but at least he has vowed, if elected, to kill
the Senate health bill. For that alone he deserves progressive Democrats’
support. Democrats in Congress area headed for a historic
and well-earned rout this November. Progressive
Democrats in House and Senate should be cutting
themselves loose as soon as possible from this sinking
ship and following the lead of Vermont’s independent
Sen. Bernie Sanders. They have a historic opportunity
to send the corporatist Democrats off to their
well-deserved demise, while forging the Congressional
core of something new: a true progressive opposition
party representing America’s working people. |