|
9 January 2010
By Jacob G.
Hornberger
Conservatives are once again on the rampage, this
time with respect to the alleged Detroit bomber.
They’re saying that he should be treated as an enemy
combatant rather than prosecuted as a criminal
defendant. Ironically, as they criticize President
Obama’s decision to treat the alleged bomber as a
criminal defendant, they block out their minds that
conservative icons George W. Bush and Dick Cheney
treated Zacharias Moussaoui, Jose Padilla, John Walker
Lindh, and many other accused terrorists as criminal
defendants. More ironic, however, is the fact that
conservatives purport to be ardent and enthusiastic
defenders of the concept known as the “rule of law.”
Go to any conservative conference in the country.
Listen to the speeches. You will inevitably hear, at
least once, some conservative expressing devotion to
“the rule of law.” Why is that ironic? Because it would be difficult
to find a better example of a violation of the rule of
law than the dual system of justice for prosecuting
suspected terrorists than that which was adopted by
the Bush administration and now embraced by the Obama
administration. What is meant by the term “the rule of law”? Some
people think that it means that people should obey the
law. Not so. What it means is that people in a society
should have to answer to a well-defined law rather
than to the arbitrary, ad hoc edicts of government
officials. Suppose, for example, there is a natural disaster
and ice producers begin charging people $100 for a bag
of ice, when the going rate before the disaster was
$10 a bag. Local officials fine the seller for
price-gouging, notwithstanding the fact that there was
no law prohibiting him from selling at whatever price
he wanted, natural disaster or not. That would constitute a violation of the rule of
law. Why? The man is having to answer to an arbitrary,
ad hoc decision of a government official, rather than
to a well-defined law, for his conduct. Now, suppose the law states: “No person shall
charge more for his product during a natural disaster
than he was charging before the disaster.” That would comply with the rule of law because now
people can look to the law for guidance on what is
legal and illegal. They don’t have to worry about
whether they’re going to be fined or punished for
engaging in conduct that doesn’t violate the law. It should be clear that while the rule of law is an
essential prerequisite for a free society, it is not a
sufficient prerequisite. For example, in our natural
disaster example, a price-control law would meet the
standard of the rule of law but would nonetheless
violate the principles of economic liberty. Everyone concedes that terrorism is a federal
criminal offense. It’s listed on the federal statute
books as a crime. The government indicts and
prosecutes people for terrorism. They’re tried in
federal district court. When they’re convicted, a
federal judge sends them to jail. The problem is that after 9/11, the government set
up a competing judicial system for handling people it
accused of terrorism. This system was established by
the Pentagon and was designed to compete against the
federal-court system. The difference between these two competing judicial
systems is white and black. The federal-court system — the one that the
Constitution set up for trying accused criminals — has
all the protections of the Bill of Rights. Its purpose
is to determine whether there is sufficient evidence
to convict a person of terrorism and, if so, to punish
him for his crime. In the event of an acquittal, this
system requires the person to be released from
custody, no matter how convinced people are that he
really did commit the crime. The Pentagon’s system is the opposite. Its
principles involve such things as a presumption of
guilt, torture of the accused, kangaroo military
tribunals, indefinite incarceration, no protection
against self-incrimination, secret evidence, and the
use of hearsay. The Pentagon’s system is designed for
one purpose: punishment of whoever the government
accuses of terrorism. Does the person accused of terrorism get to choose
which system he’ll be prosecuted under? No. That
life-changing decision is left entirely to the
government. And it is entirely discretionary and
arbitrary. How can such a dual system, based entirely
on the discretionary, arbitrary, ad hoc decisions of
government officials be reconciled with the principle
known as the rule of law? It can’t be. To put the matter more starkly, suppose, for
example, that there were two people on the Detroit
flight working in concert to blow up the plane. Under
the current post-9/11 system, U.S. officials could
treat one of them as a federal-court defendant and the
other as a Pentagon defendant, notwithstanding the
fact that they are accused of the exact same crime and
notwithstanding the fact that the two processes, and
thus the results, are so different. With the Constitution, the Framers established the
finest judicial system in history, one that is subject
to the Bill of Rights, whose principles stretch back
through centuries of American and English history. The
competing system established by the Pentagon after
9/11 is a travesty and a shame. Not only does it
violate the rule of law, it also violates fundamental
principles of justice and liberty and centuries of
English and American jurisprudence. Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of The
Future of Freedom Foundation. |