Soldier Of Conscience Granted Clemency, Released:
Imperialists Exposed
29 March 2010
By Dahr Jamail
Last August, Travis Bishop refused to serve in
Afghanistan. Having filed for Conscientious Objector
(CO) status, Bishop, based at Fort Hood, Texas, in the
US Army’s 57th Expeditionary Signal Battalion, was
court-martialed and sentenced to 12 months in a
military brig. He was released from the brig today.
Bishop served his time in Northwest Joint Regional
Correctional Facility at Fort Lewis, Washington. This
military brig is notorious for being a particularly
difficult jail to serve time.
While in the brig, Bishop was recognized by Amnesty
International and received support from hundreds of
people from around the world who wrote letters of
encouragement to him and wrote letters to Lt. Gen.
Robert Cone, the commanding general of Fort Hood,
asking for Travis to be released from prison.
During his court-martial at Fort Hood last August,
Bishop was tried by the military for his stand against
an occupation he believes is “illegal.” He insisted
that it would be unethical for him to deploy to
support an occupation he opposed on both moral and
legal grounds, thus his decision to file for CO
status. A CO is someone who refuses to participate in
combat based on religious or ethical grounds, and can
be given an honorable discharge by the military.
In February, Bishop was granted a three-month
reduction in his sentence by General Cone as a result
of a successful clemency application.
In a letter to Truthout from prison, Bishop wrote this
of his being granted clemency:
“Three months clemency. Wow. I am truly astonished.
Great for me? Sure. Great for future resisters? Even
more so. I cannot believe that I told the Army “No,”
refused to deploy, pleaded not guilty, and then
indicted the entire system and blamed my command in
court, and still merited clemency.”
Bishop’s case brings to light an important question
for those serving in the US military today - that of
the soldiers’ ability, while serving, to follow their
conscience during a time of war.
This topic was the focus of a recent conference, Truth
Commission on Conscience in War, that took place March
21-22 at the Riverside Church in New York City.
The conference brought together veterans and national
religious, academic and advocacy leaders to honor and
protect freedom of conscience in the military. It
featured testimony from recent veterans and national
experts on the moral, psychological and legal
dimensions of conscience and war.
According to a press release about the event, “The
March 21 public hearing will launch the Commission’s
eight-month campaign to bring national attention to
decisions of moral and religious conscience facing
American service members, culminating with the
Veterans Day release of the Commission’s Final
Report.”
During his court-martial, Bishop told Truthout he was
“opposed to all war,” based on his religious beliefs,
that “as a real Christian, I must be opposed to all
violence, no matter what, because that is what Jesus
taught.”
The Truth Commission chair, Rev. Dr. Kaia Stern, who
is also the director of the Pathways Home Project at
the Charles Hamilton Houston Institute for Race and
Justice at Harvard Law School, announced before the
commission:
“The United States of America is founded on principals
of political and religious freedom. When we punish the
soldier who heeds his or her moral compass, our
democracy is in grave danger.”
During the commission, Truthout spoke with Ian
Slattery, who is a member of the planning committee
for the commission, and is an associate producer of
the nationally broadcast film “Soldiers of
Conscience.”
“From our point of view, Travis’s story is indicative
of something that is a broader issue, and that is that
every service member has a conscience,” Slattery
explained to Truthout, “The meeting we had this week
in New York, and in the private meetings to follow, we
looked at stories across the board that service
members are experiencing. His story is like some of
the other CO’s we’ve seen, who’ve had their claims
denied or approved. These are folks who have chosen
the harder road - to follow the call to conscience
they’ve heard within themselves.”
According to Slattery, Bishop’s story is “a good
example of service members’ consciences not being
honored.”
One of the main points James Branum, Bishop’s civilian
lawyer, made in defense of Bishop during his
court-martial was that Bishop had never been given
proper training that would have informed him of the CO
option.
“Travis was never told about his option of
conscientious objector status,” Branum, told Truthout
last August.
Branum explained to Truthout. “If an enlisted soldier
isn’t informed that he has a right, then he
effectively does not have that right. Just one to two
days before he was set to deploy, in the midst of
moral questions, he heard about CO status.
During his trial, Bishop’s defense called two
witnesses to the stand, Pfc. Anthony Sadoski and
Specialist Michael Kern, both of whom were active-duty
soldiers at Fort Hood who said that they, too, had
never been informed that filing for CO status was an
option.
The judge in Bishop’s court-martial, Maj. Matthew
McDonald, said that whether Bishop was notified or not
about his right to file for CO status was not relevant
to the case.
“If every soldier in the Army who disobeyed an order
could claim it was because they weren’t notified of
conscientious objector status, we probably wouldn’t
have a military any more,” he added.
Branum told Truthout at the time that he felt Major
McDonald was attempting to establish a precedent with
the trial, regardless of the outcome. “We want to
change the law, and I would argue that when soldiers
are informed of their deployment, which is generally
two to six months in advance, they should be giving
training about CO status. I will argue that if you
don’t do the training, you can’t deploy.”
Questions like this and others are what Slattery and
others at the Truth Commission hope to bring to the
national stage.
“With two conflicts in the last nine years, hundreds
of thousands of service members have come home, and
we’ve yet to bring matters of conscience to the table
to talk about,” Slattery explained, “The commissioners
that met on Monday at the church will be working
together in the coming months to release a report on
Veterans Day, that may include recommendations on
policy and policy changes that will better protect the
consciences of people like Travis and those to come in
the future.”
In Bishop’s case, he had filed for CO status after his
realization that he was morally opposed to all war.
However, one of the issues of the Truth Commission was
that of selective CO’s. “One of the ironies of the
all-volunteer Army is that the only way we’ll
recognize their conscience is if they are a CO … but
Travis’s story teaches us that justice is a part of
war, and when they attempt to exercise that
conscience, they are only recognized if they are
opposed to all war,” Slattery added. “We hope this
will open up this possibility for people who come in
the future like Travis. We want to bring all this into
a discussion, and do so without being accused of being
unpatriotic, but we owe it to service members to
respect their conscience and their choices.”
The film Slattery helped produce, “Soldiers of
Conscience,” was broadcast nationally on PBS in
October 2008.
In the film, Camilo Mejia, a US Army veteran of Iraq
who was the first service member to publicly refuse to
return to Iraq, states what may well be the core
spirit of the Truth Commission and CO’s like Bishop:
“There’s no higher assertion of freedom than to follow
your conscience.”
“The film has been critical to doing what we did at
the Truth Commission,” Slattery told Truthout, “which
is to bring together people to look at an issue
considered as taboo, from different perspectives. But
the film has facilitated this and been an important
resource for folks to do this, those who are not
antiwar with those who are, along with religious
groups and other professionals.”
Rev. Dr. Rita Nakashima Brock, project director of the
Truth Commission, said of the Truth Commission:
“In his Nobel acceptance speech, President Obama
argued that nations will at times ‘find the use of
force not only necessary but morally justified,’ We
are asking: ‘What happens when service members are
asked to fight in a war they believe is not morally
justified?”
In January, VA Secretary Eric Shinseki confirmed that
young male veterans are committing suicide at an
increasing rate - losses that go uncounted as
casualties of the current US wars. At the same time,
new VA research on “moral injury” highlights the
lasting moral and psychological harm of violating
one’s sense of right and wrong in war.
It is this point the Truth Commission highlighted,
along with the need to respect not just CO’s, but
“selective conscientious objection.”
Rev. Herman Keizer Jr., the commission’s honorary
host, is a retired Army chaplain, Vietnam veteran and
former chair of the National Conference on Ministry to
the Armed Forces. Keizer is also an outspoken leader
in a growing movement for “selective conscientious
objection,” the right to object morally to a
particular war.
Current military regulations only recognize objections
to “war in any form.” In a recent letter to President
Obama, Keizer argued: “The conscience of the selective
objector deserves the same respect as the conscience
of the pacifist.”
Meanwhile, Branum plans to force the issue with the
military to at least have CO training better
represented within the military.
Branum told Truthout that he plans to take the result
of Bishop’s trial to the Military Court, the US Army
Court of Criminal Appeals, the US Military Court of
Criminal Appeals and “then Habeus Review and take it
to a civilian court, then, if necessary, the Supreme
Court.”
Branum added, “If Travis goes to jail, he wants it to
be for something. He wants it to count.” The attorney
said he will continue to demand the Army provide CO
training, “and my hope is that when troops are going
to be deployed, they’ll be read their Bishop rights.”
In another letter from prison, Bishop wrote to
Truthout about how he felt his story should inspire
future war resisters.
“I can’t wait to get out of here, if only to tell
people, “Hey! Look at me! If I can do it, surely more
people can too!!”
Now that he is free, Bishop plans to continue to speak
out about conscientious objection and work as an
advocate for other conscientious objectors.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments