Democracy Between Myth And Reality: Lobbying An Expensive
Undertaking
16 April 2010By Zafar Bangash
Delivering democracy has become the all-purpose
justification for every crime perpetrated by Western
governments against other people. It is not only used
to justify Western intervention in other countries’
internal affairs to subvert political processes but
also used to justify invasion and occupation of their
lands in order to “deliver” democracy whether they
want it or not. Gunboat diplomacy of yester-years has
been replaced by cruise missile democratization of
today.
Before we consider the nature of democracy, let us
consider some assumptions on which such projects are
launched. From the effortless superiority of the
British to the Manifest Destiny of America, the rest
of the world is expected to comply with the demands of
the West. In the past it was “British interests” that
had to be safeguarded; now “American interests” have
become sacrosanct even if in the process, millions of
people are threatened with extinction. This is evident
in Afgha-nistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Yemen as well as Iran
and the larger Persian Gulf bristling with American
warships and armed with cruise missiles. There is not
an inch of territory anywhere — on land or sea — that
is not infested with American warriors armed with
lethal weapons pushing US interests.
Several concepts have been peddled in the last two
decades in pursuit of Western interests; some have had
to be discarded because they proved untenable but
others are still in vogue. All were and are intended
to advance Western interests, made possible by
America’s vulturistic military machine. With the
demise of the Soviet Union, there was much talk about
the peace dividend. It was depressing to hear even
otherwise knowledgeable Muslims fall for such
rhetoric. The “peace dividend”, however, proved
short-lived as America, true to its militaristic
nature, launched wars of aggression in various parts
of the world. Puffed up by its quick military success
especially against Iraq in 1991, American officials as
well as media pundits started talking about the “New
World Order” in which the “new world” will now give
orders and others must obey them. The earlier rhetoric
of an inter-dependent world was replaced by the new
rhetoric of “might is right” since it was assumed that
America is the sole superpower in the world. Pax
Americana had dawned on the world; everyone must
accept what it demanded. Even inter-dependency was
narrowly defined: the resources of other people had to
be made available to the US so that it could sustain
its rapaciously extravagant lifestyle. Those that
dared resist American demands were threatened with
being bombed into the Stone Age. Both Afghanistan and
Iraq have been administered a large dose of this
medicine; Iran and Pakistan are threatened with
similar treatment.
Two other concepts are worth mentioning before we
examine the nature of Western democracy: Francis
Fukuya-ma’s End of History thesis and Samuel
Huntington’s Clash of Civilizations theory. With the
demise of Communism, Fukuyama triumphantly proclaimed
that Western liberalism underpinned by capitalism had
won so convincingly that there was no need for any
other ideas to order the affairs of the world. Mankind
had finally achieved nirvana under Western capitalist
liberalism. Hunting-ton, on the other hand, posited
the theory that the West would face its greatest
challenge from an alliance of resurgent Islam and
Confucius Communism (China). Some Muslims, in their
innocence, responded to the Clash of Civilizations
argument with a counter-proposal for a “Dialogue of
Civilizations”. Theoretically, it made sense but it
was flawed on two counts: first, the West is not a
civilization. When asked what he thought of Western
civilization, Gandhi had famously said, “It would be a
good idea.” Second, the West has never been interested
in dialogue; it demands compliance. At a time when
some Muslims were floating the dialogue proposal, the
West was already engaged in egregious crimes against
other people, primarily Muslims, in different parts of
the world. The US-led West conducts dialogue through
cruise missiles; just ask the Afghans and the Iraqis.
Prior to the US invasion of Afghanistan in October
2001, then US President George Bush had responded to a
negotiations proposal from Taliban leader Mullah Omar
with the statement, “we will see you in Kabul” as
American high altitude bombers were on their way to
obliterate whatever little was left of Afghanistan
already living in the Stone Age. America conducts
dialogue with 1,000-pound bombs.
Let us now look at democracy. The dictionary
definition of democracy is a “(State having)
government by all the people, direct or
representative; form of society ignoring hereditary
class distinctions and tolerating minority views.”
Western democracies claim their governments represent
the will of all, or a majority of the people. There is
a fundamental flaw even with this definition because
people’s thinking is based on personal interests
rather than on any higher values. Thus, if one ended
up in a colony of cannibals, then by definition, one
must accept cannibalism as a legitimate form of
living. One wonders whether the champions of democracy
would accept ending up on somebody’s dinner plate.
There are many other examples such as alcohol
consumption. It is known for its harmful effects yet a
majority of people in the West insist on the right to
consume it not only causing many accidents on roads
but also adding enormously to healthcare costs. The
same holds true for smoking and its ill effects on
health.
What is the reality of democracy in practice?
Political systems in all Western societies are tightly
controlled by the elites. People with money manipulate
the system to their advantage. The masses are simply
used as a vote bank to endorse whatever policies are
put forward by competing elites belonging to the same
class. In the past, feudal elites controlled the
system and used it to advance their landed interests;
with industrialization and development of the banking
sector, a new class of people emerged. Now
multinational corporations manipulate the system so
that their interests are protected and advanced.
People are asked to choose between the same set of
elites that represent elite interests, not those of
the masses. This has been compared to mice being asked
to choose between different colors of cats to rule
them: black, white, brown or other.
Political systems also need to be looked at a little
closer. While it is claimed that people are free to
choose, only a tiny minority of people do so in
reality. For instance, political parties are
controlled in such a way as to make it impossible for
outsiders to enter or represent the wishes of the
people. Theoretically, political parties are open to
everyone but since their operations depend on money,
they must pander to the wishes of the rich. Politics
being an expensive sport, the moneyed classes are able
to influence party policies to suit their interests.
Western political thinkers have been quite candid
about what must be done. Walter Lippmann, a leading
American journalist and political philosopher of the
20th century, wrote, “The public must be put in its
place,” so that the elite may “live free of the
trampling and the roar of a bewildered herd,” whose
“function” is to be “interested spectators of action,”
not participants. Lippmann’s worry was unfounded as
the 18th century British philosopher David Hume had
already observed two centuries earlier. He could not
contain his surprise “to see the easiness with which
the many are governed by the few; and to observe the
implicit submission with which men resign their own
sentiments and passions to those of their rulers.”
The rulers in turn are subservient to the corporate
elite. While the masses’ “interest” in the political
spectacle is maintained by a dutiful media, owned and
controlled by the same corporate elite, politics has
been turned into a sport. It has become a circus where
each player responds to the crack of the ring master’s
whip wielded by a member of the elite club. The masses
are made to believe that they are free to “choose”
their leaders but these have already been chosen for
them by the corporate elite that control the system.
The masses are asked to choose between competing elite
representatives. In any case, after elections,
unelected advisors and other parasites surround
“elected” leaders to ensure they comply with the
demands of the elites. Even when the masses are
opposed to some policies such as the wars in Iraq and
Afghanistan, their wishes are ignored. A clear
majority of people in the US, Britain and Canada are
opposed to these wars yet their rulers continue to
pursue militaristic policies by offering banal
explanations that are projected as profound statements
by the same media that is owned and controlled by the
elites. Elections make little or no difference because
no political party or leader has the courage to stand
up for truth. They must do what the elites demand.
An entire industry of lobbyists has also emerged.
Lobbying is an expensive undertaking. A small group of
people with money is able to manipulate the political
system to their advantage. In the US, the Zionist
lobby, the armaments industry and more recently the
banking industry have all shown how the system is
controlled and manipulated. No US leader has the
courage to oppose the demands of the Zionist lobby.
While millions of Americans are deprived of the right
to a decent job, housing and healthcare, billions of
dollars are funnelled to the Zionist State of Israel
each year. America’s global wars are waged on the
backs of ordinary Americans whose sons and daughters
die in distant lands so that the armaments industry
barons can make tidy profits. The gnomes of banking
lost billions of dollars in Ponzi schemes but then
demanded that the government bail them out otherwise
the entire system would collapse. Nearly $1 trillion
were handed to them while millions of people lost
their jobs and homes. How were people’s interests
safeguarded? The banking executives should have been
put on trial for fraud and handed long prison
sentences. Instead, in America’s democratic utopia,
they gave themselves billions of dollars in bonuses
while ordinary people were thrown out of their homes
and forced to live in tents.
This is how democracy works. One must express sympathy
with ordinary people but this does not put bread on
their plates.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments