|
30 May 2010 By Ramzy Baroud The debate is no longer
confined to a few academics in distant universities.
It is now a widely prevalent, mainstream topic of
discussion. How will the news of the
future be distributed? The jury is still out, but not
completely. Increasingly, we are driven to believe
that the future will be paperless. Some argue that the
“paper” will be taken out of the “newspaper” within a
few years. Their logic might have come across as
far-fetched in the late 1990s, but it can hardly be
dismissed in 2010. Two American
intellectuals added their voices to the chorus of
those predicting that the print media would not
continue to define the news for long. In October 2009,
Leonard Downie Jr., vice president at large and former
executive editor of The Washington Post, and Michael
Schudson, professor of Communication at Columbia
University’s Graduate School of Journalism,
co-authored a 98-page paper entitled, “The
Reconstruction of American Journalism.” Here, they made the
assertion that: “Newspapers and television news are
not going to vanish in the foreseeable future ... But
they will play diminished roles in an emerging and
still rapidly changing world of digital journalism, in
which the means of news reporting are being
re-invented, the character of news is being
reconstructed, and reporting is being distributed
across a greater number and variety of news
organizations, new and old.” The idea is not a new
one. In August 24, 2006, The Economist published an
article entitled, “Who killed the newspaper?,” which
claimed that, “Of all the ‘old’ media, newspapers have
the most to lose from the Internet. Circulation has
been falling in America, Western Europe, Latin
America, Australia and New Zealand for decades ... in
the past few years the Web has hastened the decline.” While we freely refer to
the digital media revolution as “new media,” few dare
classify print newspapers as “old.” The Economist did,
nearly four years ago. Considering the speed at which
the digital media world is moving — with the
introduction of new gadgets and the level of Internet
penetration throughout the world — print papers are
now most definitely old and aging. The magazine also made
an interesting reference to Philip Meyer, whose works
include, “Precision Journalism: A Reporter’s
Introduction to Social Science Methods and Newspaper
Ethics in the New Century: A Report to the American
Society of Newspaper Editors.” In his most recent book,
“The Vanishing Newspaper,” Meyer calculates that “the
first quarter of 2043 will be the moment when
newsprint dies in America as the last exhausted reader
tosses aside the last crumpled edition.” More, digital media are
making waves not just in the constant improvement of
news and information technology, but also influencing
the level of trust readers have in the new media.
Indeed, it is not just about how the news is conveyed
— digitally or on paper — but how our perception of
the news is changing altogether. American intellectual
and best-selling author John Mearsheimer didn’t
neglect to refer to the Internet in one of the most
important and honest assessments on “The Future of
Palestine.” In his recent speech, he stated that “The
Internet is a game changer. It not only makes it easy
for the opponents of apartheid to get the real story
out to the world, but it also allows Americans to
learn the story that the New York Times and the
Washington Post have been hiding from them.” Those familiar with the
book Manufacturing Consent, by Edward S. Herman and
Noam Chomsky understand well that traditional media
coverage of news is largely determined by “filters”
which allow competing interests to determine what we
read and watch, and thus our perception of the world.
The Internet, despite all its shortcomings, is much
more equitable and democratic. That should not
discount the fact that poorer countries still do not
have the kind of Internet availability, speed and
access that is common and widespread in the developed
world. But the fact that an online community newspaper
has a fighting chance, like any other mainstream
newspaper, is certainly worth celebrating as an
achievement. There is also another
reason why we will continue to go digital, and why it
will only be a matter of years before the pendulum
turns in favor of paperless media world. The latest Climate
Change conference in Copenhagen failed to set limits
on carbon emissions or to come up with any serious or
binding agreements. It was a colossal disappointment.
But that failure was political more than scientific.
Very few still argue that global warming is a hoax, or
believe that the environment is sustainable,
considering our long-unchecked way of life. More,
recycling is no longer a fad. Some countries are
debating laws that make recycling mandatory, and to
punish violators. Considering all of this, it is
difficult to imagine that years from now we will
continue to use and discard newspapers so readily, as
if the paper on which news is printed doesn’t come
from trees, and as if discarded papers don’t
constitute landfill. Bob Dylan continues to
be right. “The Times They Are a-Changin.” And it’s
time that we also appreciate that change, not resist
it; work with it, not against it. There is no shame in
embracing change. When the first commercially
successful trans-Atlantic telegraph cable was
completed in July 1866, some must have thought that
humanity had reached the zenith of achievements as far
as the field of communications was concerned. Now
telegraphs are only found in museums and are coveted
collectors’ items. Instead, hundreds of millions of
people routinely and conveniently send texts, sounds,
images and videos through their cell phones without
much fuss or excitement. Although the concept is still
the same, the medium has changed dramatically. The same can be said
about news. The news industry will never die; in fact,
in a globalized and interconnected world, we will seek
news more than ever before. But the medium will
inevitably change, and there is nothing we can do to
stop it. It is telling that the most featured and
best-selling item from Amazon.com is the Kindle
digital reader, and that iPad has been topping news
related to publishing technology all around the world. The Times They Are a-Changin’.
And we’d better change accordingly. - Ramzy Baroud (www.ramzybaroud.net)
is an internationally-syndicated columnist and the
editor of PalestineChronicle.com. His latest book is "My
Father Was a Freedom Fighter: Gaza's Untold Story"
(Pluto Press, London), now available on Amazon.com |