16 July 2010By Ellen Brown
“You all are the house, you're the bookie.
[Your clients] are booking their bets with you. I
don't know why we need to dress it up. It's a bet.”
- Senator Claire McCaskill, Senate Subcommittee
investigating Goldman Sachs (Washington Post, April
27, 2010)
Ever since December 2008, the Federal Reserve has held
short-term interest rates near zero. This was not only
to try to stimulate the housing and credit markets but
also to allow the federal government to increase its
debt levels without increasing the interest tab picked
up by the taxpayers. The total public U.S. debt
increased by nearly 50% from 2006 to the end of 2009
(from about $8.5 trillion to $12.3 trillion), but the
interest bill on the debt actually dropped (from $406
billion to $383 billion), because of this reduction in
interest rates.
One of the dire unintended consequences of that
maneuver, however, was that municipal governments
across the country have been saddled with very costly
bad derivatives bets. They were persuaded by their
Wall Street advisers to buy municipal swaps to protect
their loans against interest rates shooting up.
Instead, rates proceeded to drop through the floor, a
wholly unforeseeable and unnatural market condition
caused by rate manipulations by the Fed. Instead of
the banks bearing the losses in return for premiums
paid by municipal governments, the governments have
had to pay massive sums to the banks - to the point of
pushing at least one county to the brink of bankruptcy
(Jefferson County, Alabama).
Another unintended consequence of the plunge in
interest rates has been that “savers” have been forced
to become “speculators” or gamblers. When interest
rates on safe corporate bonds were around 8%, a couple
could aim for saving half a million dollars in their
working careers and count on reaping $40,000 yearly in
investment income, a sum that, along with social
security, could make for a comfortable retirement. But
very low interest rates on bonds have forced these
once-prudent savers into the riskier and less
predictable stock market, and the collapse of the
stock market has forced them into even more
speculative ventures in the form of derivatives, a
glorified form of gambling. Pension funds, which have
binding pension contracts entered into when interest
was at much higher levels, need an 8% investment
return to meet their commitments. In today’s market,
they cannot make that sort of return without taking on
higher risk, which means taking major losses when the
risks materialize.
Derivatives are basically just bets. Like at a
racetrack, you don’t need to own the thing you’re
betting on in order to play. Derivative casinos have
opened up on virtually anything that can go up or down
or have a variable future outcome. You can bet on the
price of tea in China, the success or failure of a
movie, whether a country will default on its debt, or
whether a particular piece of legislation will pass.
The global market in derivative trades is now well
over a quadrillion dollars – that’s a thousand
trillion – and it is eating up resources that were at
one time invested in productive enterprises. Why risk
lending money to a corporation or buying its stock,
when you can reap a better return betting on whether
the stock will rise or fall?
The shift from investing to gambling means that not
only are investors making very little of their money
available to companies to produce goods and services,
but the parties on one side of every speculative trade
now have an interest in seeing the object of the bet
fail, whether a company, a movie, a politician,
or a country. Worse, high-speed program traders can
actually manipulate the market so that the thing bet
on is more likely to fail. Not only has the market
become a casino, but the casino is rigged.
High frequency traders – a field led by Goldman Sachs
-- use computer algorithms to automatically bet huge
sums of money on minor shifts in price. These bets
send signals to the market that can themselves cause
the price of assets to shoot up or tumble down. By
placing high-volume trades, the largest speculative
traders can thus intentionally “fix” prices in any
direction they want.
“Prediction” Markets
Casinos for betting on what something will do in the
future have been elevated to the status of
“prediction” markets, and they can cover a broad range
of issues. MIT’s Technology Review launched a futures
market for technological innovations, in order to bet
on upcoming developments. The NewsFutures and
TradeSports Exchanges enable people to wager on
matters such as whether Tiger Woods will take another
lover, or whether Bin Laden will be found in
Afghanistan.
A 2008 conference of sports leaders in Auckland, New
Zealand, featured Mark Davies, head of a sport betting
exchange called Betfair. Davies observed that these
betting exchanges, while clearly gambling forums, are
little different from the trading done by financial
firms such as JPMorgan. He said:
“I used to trade bonds at JPMorgan, and I can tell you
that what our customers do is exactly the same as what
I used to do in my previous life, with the single
exception that where I had to pour over balance sheets
and income statements, they pour over form and
team-sheets.”
The online news outlet Slate monitors various
prediction markets to provide readers with up-to-date
information on the potential outcomes of political
races. Two of the markets covered are the Iowa
Electronic Markets and Intrade. Slate claims that
these political casinos are consistently better at
forecasting winners than pre-election polls.
Participants bet real money 24 hours a day on the
outcomes of a range of issues, including political
races. Newsfutures and Casualobserver are similar,
smaller exchanges.
Besides shifting the emphasis to gambling (“Why Vote
When You Can Bet?” says Slate’s “Guide to All
Political Markets”), prediction markets, like the
stock market, can be rigged so that they actually
affect outcomes. This became evident, for example, in
2008, when the John McCain campaign used the InTrade
market to shift perception of his chances of winning.
A supporter was able to single-handedly manipulate the
price of McCain’s contract, causing it to move up in
the market and prompting some mainstream media to
report it as evidence that McCain was gaining in
popularity.
Betting on Terrorism
The destructive potential of prediction markets became
particularly apparent in one sponsored by the
Pentagon, called the “policy analysis market” (PAM) or
“terror futures market.” PAM was an attempt to use the
predictive power of markets to forecast political
events tied to the Middle East, including terrorist
attacks. According to the New York Times, the PAM
would have allowed trading of futures on political
developments including terrorist attacks, coups
d’état, and assassinations. The exchange was shut down
a day after it launched, after commentators pointed
out that the system made it far too easy to make money
with terror attacks.
At a July 28, 2003 press conference Senators Byron L.
Dorgan (DND) and Ron Wyden(DOR) spoke out against the
exchange. Wyden stated, “The idea of a federal betting
parlor on atrocities and terrorism is ridiculous and
it's grotesque,” while Dorgan called it “useless,
offensive and unbelievably stupid”.
“This appears to encourage terrorists to participate,
either to profit from their terrorist activities or to
bet against them in order to mislead U.S. intelligence
authorities,” they said in a letter to Admiral John
Poindexter, the director of the Terrorism Information
Awareness Office, which developed the idea. A week
after the exchange closed, Poindexter offered his
resignation.
Carbon Credit Trading
A massive new derivatives market that could be highly
destructive economically is the trading platform
called Carbon Credit Trading, which is on its way to
dwarfing world oil trade. The program would allow
trading in “carbon allowances” (permitting companies
to emit greenhouse gases) and in “carbon offsets”
(allowing companies to emit beyond their allowance if
they invest in emission-reducing projects elsewhere).
It would also allow trading in carbon derivatives; for
example, futures contracts to deliver a certain number
of allowances at an agreed price and time.
Robert Shapiro, former undersecretary of commerce in
the Clinton administration and a cofounder of the U.S.
Climate Task Force, has warned, “We are on the verge
of creating a new trillion-dollar market in financial
assets that will be securitized, derivatized, and
speculated by Wall Street like the mortgage-backed
securities market.”
Eoin O’Carroll cautioned in the Christian Science
Monitor:
“Many critics are pointing out that this new market
for carbon derivatives could, without effective
oversight, usher in another Wall Street free-for-all
just like the one that precipitated the implosion of
the global economy. . . . Just as the inability of
homeowners to make good on their subprime mortgages
ended up pulling the rug out from under the credit
market, carbon offsets that are based on shaky
greenhouse-gas mitigation projects could cause the
carbon market to tank, with implications for the
broader economy.”
The proposed form of cap and trade has not yet been
passed in the U.S., but a new market in which traders
can speculate on the future of allowances and offsets
has already been launched. The largest players in the
carbon credit trading market include firms such as
Morgan Stanley, Barclays Capital, Fortis, Deutsche
Bank, Rabobank, BNP Paribas, Sumitomo, Kommunalkredit,
Credit Suisse, Merrill Lynch and Cantor Fitzgerald.
Last year, the financial services industry had 130
lobbyists working on climate issues, compared to
almost none in 2003. The lobbyists represented
companies such as Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan Chase.
Billionaire financier George Soros says cap-and-trade
will be easy for speculators to rig. “The system can
be gamed,” he said last July at a London School of
Economics seminar. “That’s why financial types like me
like it — because there are financial opportunities.”
Time to Board Up the Casinos and
Rethink Our Social Safety Net?
Our forebears considered gambling to be immoral and
made it a crime. As the Industrial Revolution and the
ascendance of capital changed religious mores,
gambling gradually gained acceptance, but even within
that permissive paradigm, derivative trading was
originally considered an illegal form of gambling.
Perhaps it is time to reinstate the gambling laws,
board up the derivatives casinos, and return the stock
market to what it was designed to be: a means of
funneling the capital of investors into productive
businesses.
Short of banning derivatives altogether, the
derivatives business could be slowed up considerably
by imposing a Tobin tax, a small tax on every
financial trade. “Financial products” are virtually
the only products left on the planet that are not
currently subject to a sales tax; and at over a
quadrillion dollars in trades annually, the market is
huge.
A larger issue is how to ensure adequate retirement
income for the population without forcing people into
gambling with their life savings to supplement their
meager social security checks. It may be time to
rethink not only our banking and financial structure
but the entire social umbrella that our Founding
Fathers called the Common Wealth. The genius of Social
Security was its recognition of the basic economic
truth that real “security” rests on the ability of a
society to provide for and take care of those who,
because of age, health or economic conditions, cannot
take care of themselves.
Deficit hawks cry that we cannot afford more spending;
but according to Richard Cook, a former U.S. Treasury
Department official, the government could print and
spend several trillion new dollars into the money
supply without causing price inflation. Writing in
Global Research in April 2007, he noted that the U.S.
Gross Domestic Product in 2006 came to $12.98
trillion, while the total national income came to only
$10.23 trillion; and at least 10 percent of that
income was reinvested rather than spent on goods and
services. Total available purchasing power was thus
only about $9.21 trillion, or $3.77 trillion less
than the collective price of goods and services sold.
Where did consumers get the extra $3.77 trillion?
They had to borrow it, and they borrowed it from
banks that created it with accounting entries on their
books. If the government had replaced this
bank-created money with debt-free government-created
money, the total money supply would have remained
unchanged. That means a whopping $3.77 trillion
in new government-issued money could have been fed
into the economy in 2006 without inflating prices.
Different proposals have been made concerning how this
money should be distributed, but at least some of it
could be used to provide adequate social security
checks, relieving the pressure to gamble with our
savings.
The Federal Reserve has funneled $4.6 trillion to Wall
Street in bailout money, most of it generated via
“quantitative easing” (in effect, printing money); yet
hyperinflation has not resulted. To the contrary, what
we have today is Depression-style deflation.
The M3 money supply shrank in the last year by 5.5
percent, and the rate at which it is shrinking is
accelerating. The explanation for this anomaly is that
the Fed’s $4.6 trillion added by quantitative easing
fell far short of the estimated $10 trillion needed to
“reflate” the money supply after the “shadow lenders”
disappeared. When these investors discovered that the
“triple-A” mortgage-backed securities they had been
purchasing from Wall Street were actually very risky
investments, they exited the market, credit dried up,
and the money supply (which today consists almost
entirely of credit or debt) collapsed.
The only viable way to reflate a collapsed money
supply is to put more money into it; and creating the
national money supply is the sovereign right of
governments, not of banks. If the government wants to
remain sovereign, it needs to reassert that right.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments