|
17 November 2010
By Nicola Nasser
The statement by former U.S. President George W. Bush
in his 497 page memoir of "Decision Points" that a
secret peace deal was worked out between the
then-prime minister of Israel, Ehud Olmert, and
Palestinian President, Mahmoud Abbas, which "we
devised a process to turn .. into a public agreement"
had not Olmert been ousted by a scandal to be replaced
in the following elections by Binyamin Netanyahu, who
reneged on his predecessor's commitments, is a piece
of history which highlights the fact that peace making
in the Arab Israeli conflict and the peace process
have been hostages to the rotating U.S. and Israeli
elections since the Madrid peace conference of 1991.
Of course Bush had a different point of view. In his
Rose Garden speech on Israel Palestine two-state
solution on June 24, 2002, he said that "for too long
.. the citizens of the Middle East" and "the hopes of
many" have been held "hostage" to "the hatred of a few
(and) the forces of extremism and terror," a
misjudgement that led his administration to strike a
deal with the former Israeli premier, now comatose,
Ariel Sharon to engineer a "regime change" in the
self-ruled Palestinian Authority that resulted
according to Sharon's terminology in the "removal"
of Yasser Arafat, the Palestinian leader who made
peace possible in the first place for the first time
in the past one hundred years and for that deserved to
be a Nobel Peace Laureate, to be replaced by the
incumbent Palestinian leadership of Abbas who, despite
being almost identical of both men's image of a peace
maker, is again victimized by the same rotating U.S.
and Israeli elections, much more than by what Bush
termed as "forces of extremism and terror."
Ironically, Bush's own Secretary of State, Condoleezza
Rice, some three years ago, had to admit that there is
no consensus among U.S. officials on a clear-cut
definition of "extremism and terror" when she said,
referring to acts of Palestinian anti-Israeli military
occupation, that, "The prolonged experience of
deprivation and humiliation can radicalize even normal
people." Even Olmert's care-taker successor and the
opposition leader now, Tzipporah Malkah "Tzipi" Livni,
became the first ever Israeli cabinet minister to
strike a line between an "enemy" and a "terrorist"
when she told U.S. TV show "Nightline" on March 28,
2006: "Somebody who is fighting against Israeli
soldiers is an enemy .. I believe that this is not
under the definition of terrorism."
However, judging from the incumbent Barak Obama
administration's adoption of Bush's perspectives on
the issue, as vindicated by Obama's similar stance
vis-ΰ-vis the Palestinian anti-Israeli military
resistance, in particular from the Gaza Strip, and the
Israeli captive corporal Gilad Shalit, the U.S.
successive administrations - whether Democrats or
Republicans is irrelevant are still insistent on
shooting their Middle East peace efforts in the feet
by giving the priority in peace making to fighting
"extremism and terror" rather than to make peace as
the prerequisite to ruling out the root causes of both
evils.
Once and again, then again and again, U.S. and Israeli
elections bring about new players and governments that
renege on the commitments, pledges and promises of
their predecessors vis a vis the Arab Israeli
conflict in general and the Palestinian Israeli
peace process in particular, with an overall effect of
being much more harmful to peace making than any
forces of extremism."
This overall effect is devastating. First and foremost
it creates the vicious circle of unfulfilled promises
and hopes, which in turn, secondly, undermines what
little confidence might still be there to believe in
the same pledges of the newcomers, which their
predecessors reneged on. Third, the repeatedly aborted
endeavors for a breakthrough renders the "peace
process" less an honest attempt on conflict resolution
and more a crisis management effort, which is the last
thing the Palestinian and Arab "peace partners" would
like to put on their agenda. The ensuing environment
of these and other factors is, fourth, the ideal
setting for opening a new "window of opportunity" as
soon as an old one is closed for "the forces of
extremism" to exploit the political vacuum thus
created. By default or by decision extremists in the
Arab Israeli conflict are U.S. and Israeli made as
well as they are a legitimate byproduct of a failed
process where the mission of peace making has been
moving on from an old administration to a new one,
each with a new plan that hardly takes off before
another is offered by new players.
The outcome of the latest U.S. mid-term elections was
not an exception. Both Palestinian and Israeli
protagonists were on edge "waiting" for a new equation
that would change the balance of power between the
incumbent administration and the Congress to serve
their respective goals and expectations, and a change
did occur that will curtail the ability of President
Obama to follow up on his pledges to deliver on his
promises of peace making. The Palestinian
disappointment is on the verge of despair to consider
alternatives to the U.S. sponsorship of peace making,
let alone continuing a peace process that has been
counterproductive all along. The Israeli jubilation is
on the verge of declaring an Israeli victory in a
non-Israeli U.S. Congress over a U.S president who
never even thought of compromising the U.S. Israeli
strategic alliance or the decades old commitment of
successive administrations to the security of Israel,
but only pondered a non-binding plan to bring the
protagonists together to decide for themselves through
strictly bilateral direct negotiations that rule
beforehand any external intervention.
Obama's plan, to all practical reasons, is thus
aborted in the bud and its file is about to be
archived on top of the pile of the older files of the
earlier plans of presidents Reagan, Bush senior,
Clinton and Bush junior, which were swept away to the
dustbin of history by the rotating U.S. or Israeli
elections, while holding the Palestinian negotiator
hostage to a process that nothing indicates it will
ever end, waiting for the U.S. Godot.
Holding the Palestinian negotiator hostage to this
open-ended U.S.-sponsored process is now and has been
always the only game in town for the Israelis, the
only beneficiaries of the ever explosive status quo of
the Arab Israeli conflict, who have been exploiting
the peace process as a playground to win more time to
create more facts on the ground that will sooner or
later render the temporary status quo created by their
military occupation of 1967 into a permanent regional
arrangement.
Netanyahu's anti-Oslo campaign was interpreted to
create the political environment that contributed to
the assassination of Yitzhaq Rabin on November 4,
1995, two years after signing the Oslo agreement
(Declaration of Principles) with Arafat - who was
suspiciously poisoned to death on November 11, 2004 -
and Netanyahu's election to the premiership
immediately thereafter was interpreted as an
anti-peace coup d'etat. When the 1999 elections
brought back to power the so-called "peace camp" led
by Labor, PM Ehud Barak did not bring the "peace
process" back to Rabin track, but reneged on the
signed agreements, refused to implement the imminent
and final withdrawal from the West Bank and succeeded,
with U.S. help, in dragging the Palestinian side to
jump to the intractable final status issues. The
following elections followed the collapse of the Camp
David trilateral summit and the ensuing violence,
which led the new premier, Ariel Sharon, to declare
the death of Oslo accord. Sharon succeeded in
recruiting the support of George W. Bush to put the
change of the Palestinian Authority (PA) regime of
Arafat as the only item on the agenda of the "peace
process" as a precondition to its resumption and
convinced Bush to delay the official launch of the
"Road Map" until after the Israeli elections. All that
done already, and a new PA regime of their liking is
already in place, but the Map has yet to be
implemented. Two years ago, Obama had a plan to
negotiate how to renegotiate the Road Map, but the
latest Israeli elections brought to power Netanyahu
who seems determined to negotiate only on how to
implement his own unilateral plans.
No surprise then Palestinian negotiators are almost
concluding that enough is enough, that they are left
with no options but to get rid of this rotating
electoral vicious circle and let come whatever, it
would not be worse than the current status of being
captives to a waiting game for a Godot that will never
come.
* Nicola Nasser is a veteran Arab journalist based in
Bir Zeit, West Bank of the Israeli-occupied
Palestinian territories. |