12 December 2010 By Tariq Alhomayed The world and the media have been preoccupied in
the past few days with the ‘Wikileaks' documents.
These leaked government cables were considered purely
an American scandal, but please…today we have our own
scandal! From reading the documents published in the
western press, and then comparing them with the
translations published in some Arab newspapers, it is
surprising that some Arab media outlets are committing
forgery, rather than mere selective editing (the media
is selective by nature). Some statements have been
attributed to the wrong people, and attitudes have
been distorted. The matter does not end here; indeed some Iranian
news agencies have entered the scene in their own way.
One such agency attributed a statement to a Saudi
diplomat, saying that he completely rejected the
leaked information from the U.S. government cables. Of
course, this news was picked up by some Arab
newspapers and websites, and this inevitably serves
the objectives of Iran in the region. This is what I
always call the process of ‘laundering the news',
where news is published first on an Iranian website,
and soon you find it has spread like wildfire, and
then God help those who want to deny or correct it.
The day before yesterday, the ‘Mehr' Iranian news
agency attributed quotes to the Saudi Charge
d'Affaires in Tehran, saying that he refuted Saudi
King Abdullah bin Abdulaziz's reported statements
about Iran in the ‘Wikileaks' documents. The agency
added that the Saudi Charge d'Affaires, revealed as
Fouad al-Qassas, had denied all information revealed
in the documents, in its entirety. This news was
immediately picked up by pro-Iranian newspapers. For me, this was a confusing matter, because I have
a good relationship with the Saudi diplomat Fouad al-Qassas,
and I know that he left his post in Tehran several
months ago, after a Saudi Ambassador was appointed
there, and he has now begun work in Riyadh. I
contacted Mr. Fouad al-Qassas to inquire about this,
and he was surprised, saying: "I did not speak with
anyone, nor did I declare anything. I have no
connection with the Saudi Embassy in Tehran.
Currently, I am beginning my work in the ministry in
Riyadh, and there is a Saudi Ambassador in Tehran by
the name of Muhammad ibn Abbas al-Kalabi!" There is an interesting fact that ‘Mehr' news
agency should take note of. It is diplomatic custom to
appoint a Charge d'Affaires in the absence of an
Ambassador, and it is well known, and well documented,
that the Saudi Ambassador to Iran was inaugurated by
the Iranian President on the 14th of June 2010! This story is only the tip of the iceberg, and it
is clear that some Arab media distorts and forges the
information it receives. We are dealing with 250,000
documents here. So, who is going to double check the source
materiel and be accountable? This brings up a story worth mentioning. At the
beginning of my journalism career, I was asked by an
editor of a newspaper I was working for to come up
with a front page headline relating to Osama bin
Laden. I told him directly that I was not familiar
with the information mentioned in the story, to which
he laughed and said "a man once told a group of
friends that there are exactly a million stars in the
sky. Puzzled, they asked him how he knew? The man
replied "count them". The Editor looked at me smiling
and said "who's going to check…publish and let's sell
newspapers!" It seems that the Arab media still works this way,
unfortunately.
Tariq Alhomayed is the Editor-in-Chief of Asharq Al-Awsat, the youngest
person to be appointed that position. He holds a BA degree in Media studies from
King Abdul Aziz University in Jeddah, and has also completed his Introductory
courses towards a Master's degree from George Washington University in
Washington D.C. He is based in London. Comments 💬 التعليقات |