Mafia-controlled Russia Was And Is A Hyphenated
'Democracy'
02 January 2011By Markaz Kavkaz
Radio Liberty published an article about the lack of
democracy in the KGB-ruled Russia. The article says:
"As a new decade begins, is Russia ready to go beyond
being a hyphenated democracy to becoming a real one?
One might think so, listening to Medvedev's keynote
democracy speech this year. The occasion was the
Yaroslavl Global Policy Forum in September, where he
argued forcefully that Russia fully subscribed to the
universal standards of democracy. He said that if
Russia fell short of those standards, it was only
because democracy is still new in the country.
Medvedev's rhetoric was attention-getting because it
suggested the Kremlin is abandoning its long-standing
argument that Russia is a "special case" democracy
justifying many authoritarian practices.
That exceptional form of democracy -- branded
"sovereign democracy" by Kremlin political strategist
Surkov -- set Russia's goal as becoming a stable
"democratic" state by concentrating power in the hands
of a strong leader supported by a dominant party. The
leader, of course, was then president Vladimir Putin
and the dominant party the ruling United Russia which
was formed to support him.
Throughout Asia, sovereign democracy remains a growth
business. Whether it's called managed democracy,
nationalist democracy, or given no name at all, it is
the top-down system seen from Central Asia to
Singapore, where governments give citizens increasing
economic and social liberties but monopolize political
power.
The argument is always that full democracy is not
suited to local conditions and that loosening the
government's monopoly on power and key sectors of the
economy would invite chaos, set back economic
progress, and not be in the "national interest."
China equally fits the bill, although Beijing's
leaders make no pretense of striving for any type of
democracy, modified or otherwise.
No wonder, then, that the leaked diplomatic cables
from the U.S. Embassy in Moscow offer such a frank and
bleak assessment of affairs in Russia. Russia has
become a virtual mafia state.
In one cable, U.S. Ambassador John Beyrle reports that
"the Moscow city government's direct links to
criminality have led some to call it 'dysfunctional'
and to assert that the government operates more as a
kleptocracy than a government." Another leaked cable
quotes U.K. Foreign Office Russia director Michael
Davenport as saying Russia is a "corrupt autocracy."
And in yet another leaked cable, U.S. Defense
Secretary Robert Gates says that "Russian democracy
has disappeared".
"It is important to recognize that what they are
suggesting is really a twisted definition of
democracy. These are authoritarian regimes that don't
permit meaningful discussion of political issues, they
don't permit meaningful political competition, they
don't permit judicial independence, they routinely
abuse civil society," says Christopher Walker,
director of studies for the U.S.-based democracy
watchdog Freedom House. "So, any kind of meaningful
discussion of liberal democracy is a nonstarter in
this context".
Walker suggests one reason may be that in today's
world it is hard for any government -- even
authoritarian ones - to speak in nondemocratic terms.
The triumph of democracy in the Cold War dealt severe
blows to totalitarianism and ideologies associated
with it. So much so, that it is almost impossible to
go against democracy as the global brand.
"The leadership doesn't feel comfortable simply saying
that they are developing a new form of
authoritarianism," Walker says. "They are very careful
both for their domestic and international audiences to
arrogate the term democracy for their own purposes.
So, the battle is really over how the term democracy
is interpreted".
If the issue how to interpret democracy, one of the
most interesting aspects of Medvedev's speech this
year would be how much it signals that Moscow has
decided to present Russia's flawed vision of democracy
as an example of universal democratic values, pure and
simple.
That strikes many democracy advocates as more
dangerous than Russia's past attempts to claim it was
developing its own "national" species of the ideal.
Then, at least, there was the need for Russia to make
a case that the exception was as good as the rule -- a
case that was hard to make.
"What the free world is facing today is not the
challenge of any ideology but the challenge of the
'free riders.' Both Russia and China are much more
trying to play a parasitical role with regards to
Western institutions and Western ideas than to come up
with a clear alternative," says Ivan Krastev of the
Sofia-based Center for Liberal Strategies. "Because
coming with a clear alternative also means being
accountable for what you are doing".
Krastev adds that the Kremlin leaders are too
opportunistic to develop new ideologies of their own.
He says they tried that and found it both burdensome
for themselves and unappealing to a domestic audience
already exhausted by the ideological contortions of
the communist era.
"The only serious attempt was after the Ukrainian
Orange Revolution when the Russian leadership invested
quite a lot of energy and resources in the idea of
'sovereign democracy'," Krastev says. "But in the last
two or three years it is much more interesting to see
that Russia is trying to portray itself much more as a
variant of Western democracy while talking of Russian
specifics, than it is claiming they have an
alternative model, especially any model they want to
export anywhere".
Instead, Russian leaders have found it is far easier
and more expedient to talk about already being a
democracy while running a state that -- beneath the
rhetoric -- remains as authoritarian as ever. The talk
helps to insulate Moscow from the harsh criticism that
is leveled upon states that reject democratic values.
And it helps to disarm critics by holding out the
possibility that tomorrow -- if not today -- the
promises of democracy may yet become reality.
But the same polished talk should not be allowed to
mask those telling moments when Russian leaders speak
of their feelings about democracy in more spontaneous
and less complimentary terms. Medvedev had one of
those moments in 2010 and it was memorable.
In June, Medvedev criticized Kyrgyzstan's efforts to
become the first parliamentary democracy in Central
Asia by saying, "Taking into account the fact that
even now the authorities are unable to impose
order...I do not really understand how a parliamentary
republic would look and work" there.
Speaking on the sidelines of the G20 meeting in
Toronto, he added, "Will this not lead to a chain of
eternal problems -- to reshuffles in parliament, to
the rise to power of this or that political group, to
authority being passed constantly from one hand to
another, and, finally, will this not help those with
extremist views to power?"
Those are the kinds of worries authoritarians can't
help but voice when confronted with efforts to build
democracy at their front door. And they show how
little the thinking in Moscow may really have
changed".
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments