|
24 January 2011 By Ramzy Baroud When faced with problems, most
authoritarian regimes maintain a policy of rigidity
when the appropriate response would be flexibility,
political wisdom and concessions. This policy gives
authoritarian leaders their ability to control their
populations to serve the interests of a few
individuals and political and military elites. It can
also, however, usher their downfall, for populations
can only be oppressed, controlled and punished to a
point. President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali
of Tunisia, who controlled his population with an iron
fist since his arrival to the presidential palace in
1987, must have crossed that point. He was forced to
flee the country amid the angry chants of thousands of
Tunisians, fed up with growing unemployment, soaring
inflation, government corruption, violent crackdowns
and lack of political freedom. These mounting
frustrations led to relentless protests throughout the
country. The government's subsequent crackdowns only
stirred emotions beyond any crowd control strategy,
and eventually Ben Ali's plane left to seek refuge
outside his own country. The upheaval in Tunisia is
certainly worthy of all the headlines, media
commentary and official statements it has generated.
But many of these reactions contain generalizations
that hype expectations, worsen an already terrible
situation and provoke misguided policies. Indeed, the
current political storm, dubbed both the "Youth
Intifada" and the "Jasmine Revolution", has inspired
many interpretations. Some commentators wished to see
the popular uprising as a prelude to an essentially
anti-Arab regimes phenomenon that will strike
elsewhere as well, while others placed it within a
non-Arab context, noting that popular uprisings are
growing in countries that struggle with rising food
prices. Even al-Qaeda had a take on the situation,
trying to score points to find a place in the looming
political void. Many commentators have focused on
the Arab identity of Tunisia to find correlations
elsewhere. Hadeel al-Shalchi's Associated Press
article "Arab activists hope Tunisia uprising brings
change," presented the uprising within an Arab
context. Reporting from Cairo, she wrote of the
growing optimism among those whom she dubbed "Arab
activists" that other Arab leaders will share the fate
of Ben Ali if they don't ease their grip on power.
Hossam Bahgat is one such activist. He told AP, "I
feel like we are a giant step closer to our own
liberation… What's significant about Tunisia is that
literally days ago the regime seemed unshakeable, and
then eventually democracy prevailed without a single
Western state lifting a finger." True, both Tunisia and Egypt are
Arab countries with many similarities, but expecting a
repeat of a scenario that was uniquely Tunisian and
implicitly suggesting that Western states serve as
harbingers of democracy is illusory, to stay the
least. Now that Ben Ali is out of the
picture, Western governments are cautiously lining up
behind the Tunisian uprising, but hardly with the same
enthusiasm of their support of the Iranian riots of
June 2009. British Foreign Secretary William Hague
merely denounced the unrest, calling for "restraint
from all sides." He stated, "I condemn the violence
and call on the Tunisian authorities to do all they
can to resolve the situation peacefully." US President
Barack Obama added, "I urge all parties to maintain
calm and avoid violence, and call on the Tunisian
government to respect human rights, and to hold free
and fair elections in the near future." Clichéd statements aside, both
the US and the UK must fear the repercussions of a
popular uprising in an area so close to the heart of
American-British interests in the Middle East. Both
countries are careful not to appear to oppose
democratic reforms, even if they are forced to disown
their friends in the region. Their response is largely
representative of official responses from many Western
capitals – the very capitals that lauded Tunisia as a
model for how Arab countries can help win the war on
terror. One must not let confusing media
headlines sideline the fact that neither the US nor
the UK had Tunisia on their radar for circumventing
democracy or violating human rights. Ben Ali was
celebrated as an icon of moderation, notwithstanding
his atypical Arab stance on the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict. Ben Ali's authoritarian regime
was not the type that required much chastising. It was
the benign kind that allowed a tiny space for secular
opposition while cracking down on any Islamic
opposition group. For 23 years, such practice was
barely problematic, for it served the interests of
both Ben Ali and various Western powers. The countless
calls for respect of human rights from international
and local organizations were mostly unheeded.
Washington and London rarely found that irksome. Now that the Tunisian people's
fight for rights has taken a sharp turn, many of us
find it difficult to examine the specific context of
this case without delving into dangerous
generalizations. Western governments now speak of
democracy in the region – as if there were ever a
genuine concern; commentators speak of the next regime
to fall – as if every Arab country is a duplication of
another; and technology bloggers are celebrating
another ‘twitter revolution.' Perhaps generalizations make
things more interesting. Tunisia, after all, is a
small country, and most people know little about it
aside from the fact that it's a cheap tourist
destination - thus the need to place it within a more
gripping context. Al-Qaeda in Islamic Maghreb (AQIM)
is using the opportunity to read the Tunisian uprising
in a unique way. The AQIM leader, Abu Musab Abdul
Wadud, has called for the overthrowing of the
"corrupt, criminal and tyrannical" regimes in both
Tunisia and Algeria and the instatement of al-Sharia
law. This call has promoted American commentators to
warn of the future Islamization of Tunisia and will
likely result in Western intervention to ensure that
another "moderate" regime succeeds the one that just
fled. There is no harm in expanding a
popular experience to understand the world at large
and its conflicts. But in the case of Tunisia, it
seems that the country is largely understood within a
multilayer of contexts, thus becoming devoid of any
political, cultural or socio-economic uniqueness.
Understanding Tunisia as just another "Arab regime",
another possible podium for al-Qaeda's violence, is
convenient but also unhelpful to any cohesive
understanding of the situation there and the events
that are likely to follow. - Ramzy Baroud is an internationally-syndicated
columnist and the editor of PalestineChronicle.com.
His latest book is
My Father Was a Freedom Fighter: Gaza's Untold
Story (Pluto Press, London), now
available on Amazon.com. You can visit his website
through this link:
www.ramzybaroud.net. |