Furious Reaction To Al-Jazeera Documents: Willing To Cede Large Parts To Israel
06 February 2011By Khaled Amayreh
Revelations contained in Palestinian documents leaked
to the television channel Al-Jazeera this week left
Palestinian negotiators with much explaining to do,
writes Khaled Amayreh in Ramallah
The Palestinian Authority (PA) reacted with shock and
fury to revelations made by the Arab satellite TV
channel Al-Jazeera this week that it had received
leaked documents showing that Palestinian negotiators
had been ready to make far-reaching concessions to
Israel on cardinal issues of the Arab-Israeli
conflict, including Jerusalem and the right of return
for millions of Palestinian refugees.
The seemingly authentic documents, on which PA
negotiators' signatures can be seen, largely consist
of the minutes of meetings held between Israeli and
Palestinian negotiators. American officials and
mediators also took part in some of these meetings.
The documents show Palestinian negotiators as having
been willing to cede large parts of East Jerusalem to
Israel, including most if not all the colonies built
in the Jerusalem region east of the former armistice
line since 1967.
The PA is also shown as having been ready effectively
to liquidate the paramount right of return of
Palestinian refugees by entertaining ideas that
proposed the repatriation of a negligible number of
refugees to their original homeland in what is now
Israel.
Similarly, the documents, now dubbed the "Palestinian
Papers", show a clear PA propensity to cooperate and
occasionally even to collaborate with Israel against
the Islamist group Hamas, especially during the
all-out Israeli onslaught on the Gaza Strip nearly two
years ago.
While the papers contain very few real secrets, as
details of the Israeli-Palestinian negotiations since
the Oslo Accords of 1992 are widely known among
journalists and academics, this is the first time it
has become known that the PA had been willing to
abandon, or at least evade, long-held Palestinian
national constants that had come to form the closest
thing to a Palestinian consensus.
These constants enjoy general acceptance by all the
Palestinian political factions, including Hamas and
Fatah, the two largest political movements in occupied
Palestine.
It is not yet certain who leaked the documents to Al-Jazeera.
Some Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) officials
allege that an insider from the PLO negotiations
department leaked them for mercenary reasons, while
others accuse the hawkish Israeli Foreign Minister
Avigdor Lieberman of deliberately leaking the
documents in order to embarrass and therefore weaken
the PA leadership in the hope of blackmailing it into
further concessions.
Whatever the identity of the leakers turns out to be,
the leaks are unlikely to be very consequential, given
the known positions of both sides.
PA officials reacted angrily to the revelations,
accusing Al-Jazeera of attempting to carry out a
character assassination of the PA and tarnish its
image. One PA official went as far as to charge that
the Qatar-based network had "declared war" on the PA
and was working with Israel to undermine the
Palestinian cause.
Some Fatah supporters tried to storm Al-Jazeera's
offices in Ramallah but were dispersed by police.
Many Palestinians among the more educated segments of
the population have scoffed at the near hysterical
manner in which PA officials have received the
revelations, judging that there is no smoke without
fire.
PA chief negotiator Saeb Ereikat, who appeared on Al-Jazeera
as the network was broadcasting its report on the
documents, seemed unprepared and shaken by the
revelations, even losing his composure when responding
to questions about documents bearing his signature.
The following day, the PA instructed Yasser Abed Rabbo,
the secretary-general of the PLO, to launch a scathing
attack on Al-Jazeera and Qatar, including the
country's emir, Hamad bin Khalifa Al-Thani.
Abed Rabbo said that Qatar was in no position to
lecture the Palestinian people and its leadership on
patriotism, adding that the existence of a large
American military base in Qatar, as well as the
emirate's relations with Iran and its support for
"sectarian forces" (a possible allusion to Hizbullah),
made Qatar unfit to tell Palestinians what they should
think or do.
However, Abed Rabbo's remarks appeared to be off the
subject at hand, as he refused to discuss the serious
aberrations from the declared Palestinian stance that
appear in the documents.
"Some of these remarks were jokes and human reflexes
that were not meant to be formal positions," said an
angry-looking Abed Rabbo.
"I must also thank his highness the emir of Qatar for
his promoting the issue of transparency in the hope
that he will now expand it to include the American
military base in Qatar, especially its role in spying
on the Arab nations."
The most moderate reaction came from PA President
Mahmoud Abbas, who described the negotiation documents
as "nothing new."
"I don't know how Al-Jazeera obtained all these
'secrets', because there is nothing secret about the
negotiations with Israel. Everything we do with regard
to the negotiations we inform our Arab brothers and
[Arab League Secretary-General] Amr Moussa about,"
Abbas told reporters in Cairo.
Nonetheless, Abbas seemed to have decided to take
measures against Al-Jazeera. Fatah sources said a
circular had been sent to all Fatah members
instructing them to boycott the channel.
A few hours later, Nabil Shaath, a high-ranking Fatah
official, appeared on the network, saying that Al-Jazeera
should not attempt to make an issue out of every word
or observation appearing in the documents.
"It was agreed from the very beginning that nothing is
finished until everything is finished. So what is
written in these documents has no practical value,"
Shaath said.
Shaath was silent, however, when interrupted by one of
Al-Jazeera's presenters, who argued that the
observations appearing in the documents showed at
least a propensity on the part of PA negotiators to
compromise on paramount issues related to Palestinian
rights, such as Jerusalem and the right of return for
the refugees.
As expected, Hamas also castigated the PA for "hiding
the truth from the Palestinian people and for showing
a willingness to sell out on inalienable Palestinian
rights."
"We consider these documents to be further evidence of
the security and political decadence to which the PA
has stooped," said Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri.
"The documents show that the PA is not to be trusted
in leading the Palestinian people towards freedom and
liberation."
Another Islamist spokesman, Mahmoud Zahar, called on
Arab populations to take to the streets to declare
their rejection of PA "treachery and capitulation."
While the bombshell of the papers may undermine
overall Palestinian standing, some pundits have argued
that Al-Jazeera's revelations may also have a
long-term positive effect.
They argue that Palestinian negotiators will think
twice from now on before ceding to Israel on sensitive
matters such as Jerusalem and the refugees, knowing
the angry reactions to any capitulations to Israel.
(end)
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments