What Lies Behind Netanyahu's Bluster On
'1967 Borders'
02 May 2011
By Juan Cole
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu's high dudgeon over
the world community's demand that Israel return more
or less to '1967 borders' plays to two audiences, his
domestic constituency among far rightwing ‘Greater
Israel' parties intent on usurping Palestinian land,
and his American constituency among the third or so of
US Jews who oppose trading land for peace.
For the rest of us in the US, being yoked to
Netanyahu's angry expansionism is like being forced to
date Charlie Sheen. It won't do our own reputation any
good, and it won't rescue him from his
self-destructiveness.
The '1967' borders are actually those that obtained
before Israel launched its 1967 ‘Six-Day War' on
Syria, Jordan and Egypt. (There is no doubt that
Israel launched this war, and that its aggressiveness
with Syria in the previous six months contributed
mightily to the tensions that led to it.)
The reason Israel has to go back to 1967 borders is
that the annexation of territory from a neighbor
through warfare is illegal according to the United
Nations Charter, which is a treaty to which Israel and
the United States are both signatories. ‘Greater
Israel' apologists attempt to get out of this
difficulty by saying that countries used to conquer
land away from their neighbors all the time. This is a
bogus argument, since countries used to do a lot of
things, including sponsor the slave trade; Britain
even insisted on China allowing the sale of opium in
the early 19th century. The world changed when World
War II ended and the countries of the world
established the United Nations to forestall any
recrudescence of Axis techniques of conquest and rule.
If Israel does not believe in the UN Charter, it
should renounce its UN membership.
It is not just the UN Charter. The Hague Agreement of
1907 and the Geneva Convention of 1949 forbid a power
occupying enemy territory in war time from annexing it
or in any way changing the life ways of its people.
Another bogus argument the Greater Israel
expansionists trot out is that the UN Charter only
forbids the acquisition of territory from other
countries, and the Palestinians did not have a
country, and so they are fair game. This argument is
morally despicable, since the Israelis made the
Palestinians stateless, thwarting the intention of the
League of Nations that Palestine become a state; and
now they are using the abjectness and statelessness as
an argument that Palestinians can be stolen from at
will. But the argument is also incorrect. Both the
League of Nations and the UN made it perfectly clear
that they intended that the Palestinians have a state
in the future, so in preventing this from happening
the Israelis are defying international law. The 1947
UN Partition Plan, the legitimacy of which the Israeli
government says it recognizes, awarded Gaza and the
West Bank to the Palestinians. So it is not true that
these territories are no-man's land or that there is
no legal framework for their people's existence, such
that anyone could enslave them or expropriate them at
will.
Netanyahu's argument for not going back to 1967
borders is that it is inconvenient. He says that the
1967 borders are indefensible. This assertion is a
logical fallacy, known as special pleading. You can't
launch a war and annex your neighbor's territory
because you fear that your own presents security
challenges. Lots of countries are unhappy with their
borders. Saddam Hussein annexed Kuwait in 1990 in part
because he felt that the British had erred in not
giving modern Iraq a deep water port, which made Iraq
‘indefensible' and put it at an economic disadvantage.
Pakistan believes that its failure to secure the
headwaters of the Indus Valley rivers in Kashmir in
1947 puts it at a permanent disadvantage vis-a-vis
India and makes the country overly vulnerable
(‘indefensible'). Netanyahu's immoral argument that a
country just has to take by main force whatever it
feels will make it more secure is astonishing and is a
standing danger to world peace if it were taken
seriously by other countries.
Aljazeera English reports on Netanyahu's rejection of
1967 borders and anything like them:
International law forbids Israel to colonize the West
Bank– not only the UN Charter but also the Geneva
Conventions of 1948.
But beyond the specious character of Netanyahu's
rhetoric (according to which it would have been
perfectly all right for George W. Bush to annex Iraq
to the United States), the fact is that the whole tiff
over '1967 borders' is a smokescreen for Israeli
expansionism. The settler movement could put down
settlements in much of the sparsely populated south of
Israel proper with no problem. Instead, they insist on
taking Palestinian land. They are not colonizing the
West Bank only to make it more ‘secure' (they are
making it less so), but rather out of greed, ambition,
and expansionism. It is not about defense, it is about
offense.
(Courtesy the BBC)
The Likud Party led by Netanyahu does not believe in
allowing the Palestinians to have a state, and does
not believe in withdrawing from the Occupied
Territories. This obstinate stance and commitment to
undermining the international rule of law is why there
is no point in ‘engaging' the Likud with ‘
compromises.' Netanyahu led the charege against the
Oslo Peace process pursued by then PM Yitzhak Rabin in
the early 1990s, and when Rabin was assassinated and
Netanyahu came briefly to power he did whatever he
could to destroy the peace process. He admitted this
obstructionism on tape:
Netanyahu rudely lectured President Obama in front of
the cameras that the Palestinian desire to see the
return of some of the refugees expelled from their
homes by the Israelis in 1948 ‘isn't going to happen'
and he urged Obama to frankly tell the Palestinians
that it isn't going to happen. But he may as well also
have instructed Obama to tell the Palestinians that
the two state solution is dead.
Israel by now has not only planted colonies all over
the West Bank and moved hundreds of thousands of
people in, but it has secretly withdrawn residency
rights from 140,000 Palestinians. The ‘separation
barrier' removed another 12 percent of Palestinian
territory. No one can look at a map of Gaza and the
West Bank as they actually exist and see a viable
state that could protect the rights of its citizens
(the point of a state). Israel keeps announcing new
settlements or expansions of existing ones on
Palestinian territory.
Netanyahu is saying ‘no' to peace, ‘no' to
negotiations, ‘no' to dignity and rights for
Palestinians for generations to come.
Ben Franklin said that ‘Experience keeps a dear
school, but fools will learn in no other.' Netanyahu's
children and grandchildren and great grandchildren
will one day regret that he slapped away the hand of
help and the good will of Barack Obama in favor of a
stubborn and greedy Israeli expansionism.
The most likely outcome of Israel's present course is
a one state solution, achieved over decades, with much
heartbreak and violence and ruined lives in the
meantime. The Jews of Israel will likely end up like
the Maronite Christians of Lebanon. France created
Lebanon in 1920 for a then Christian majority, but
Christian out-migration and rapid Muslim population
growth reduced the Maronites to only about 22 percent
of the population today if we count children.
Likewise, Israeli Jews have already lost their
majority among first-graders in what was Mandate
Palestine in favor of Palestinians and
Palestinian-Israelis. Current demographic trends will
likely produce an Israel that is a third Arab by 2030
and that is not even counting the Occupied
Territories. The instability in the Arab world and the
Greater Middle East, which is growing, could well over
time increase Jewish out-migration (out of sheer
nervousness) so that it outstrips in-migration of
Jews. I can't see a way for Israel to escape this
demographic and geopolitical fate and remain viable as
a nation-state. Plans on the Israeli right to
denaturalize and expel the 1.5 million
Palestinian-Israelis are unrealistic and do not reckon
with the likely backlash from the Arab world, which
won't remain weak and abject forever. (We can already
see glimmerings of a new, more assertive Egypt).
The course Netanyahu is charting will harm the United
States in so many ways they are hard to count. But he
is also digging the grave of his own vision of a
Jewish state.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments