The Camp David Treaty Is Not A Sacred
Text
07 Jan 2012
By Khalid Amayreh
It is quite heartening that leaders of the Egyptian
Muslim Brothers are speaking of their disdain and
contempt of the 1979 Peace Treaty between Egypt and
Israel.
It seems also prudent that the Islamist party,
evidently the largest in Egypt, will not embark on a
rash feat that could invite uncalculated reactions
from the Zionist entity and its western allies,
especially her guardian-ally, the United States.
The Muslim Brothers have said that they will respect
Egypt's international obligations.
None the less, the Camp David treaty was not really a
treaty of peace, but rather a treaty of submission and
capitulation to Zionist regional hegemony, arrogance
and military supremacy.
True, the Sinai Peninsula was "returned" to Egypt to
the last inch. However, it is also true that vast
swathes of the Sinai desert became off limit to the
Egyptian forces. This is why smugglers, terrorists,
saboteurs and foreign agents seem to act freely
throughout that territory, blowing up gas pipelines,
smuggling narcotics and other contrabands, and even
attacking symbols of Egyptian sovereignty, including
police centers and tourist resorts.
The defunct Egyptian regime of ex President Hosni
Mubarak claimed mendaciously that the Sinai desert was
completely liberated from the Israeli occupation. But
how can Sinai are really completely liberated when the
bulk of its territory is still off limit to the
Egyptian army and air force?
In addition, it is quite scandalous how Israel came to
understand the infamous treaty, e.g. that it gave the
Zionist entity a carte blanch to gang up on the
Palestinians, liquidate the Palestinian cause, though
gradually and by desensitizing the world's moral
conscience, and carrying out recurrent genocidal
campaigns aimed at murdering, incinerating and maiming
as many Palestinians as possible.
If evidence were needed, we are all invited to revisit
the 2008-09 Israeli blitzkrieg on the Gaza Strip which
did to Gaza what the allies bombing did to Dresden in
the last phases of the Second World War.
Well, under these circumstances, one is prompted to
ask whether Egypt, especially under an Islamist-ruled
or Islamist influenced regime, is under any legal or
moral obligation to abide by such a treaty.
Of course, the final say in this regard belongs to the
Egyptian people. But the Egyptian people, who have
suffered so much and for so long from Israeli
criminality and aggression, and barbarianism doesn't
seem to give that treaty the benefit of the doubt,
that is if there is any doubt about the treaty's
ignominious nature and disastrous legacy.
I realize that spasmodic and uncalculated statements
may do more harm than good. However, there should be
no question as to the pressing need to renegotiate
that treaty if only because the government that signed
that treaty back in 1979 was not a democratic
government, which didn't enjoy the Egyptian people's
acceptance.
This week, a Muslim Brotherhood's leader, Rashad
Bayoumy, made it very clear that the Brotherhood will
not recognize the "criminal state of Israel."
"Is it a pre-condition to recognize Israel in order to
govern? This is not possible, no matter what the
circumstances are. We don't recognize Israel at all.
It is a criminal occupier."
Bayoumy, who is deputy to the Brotherhood's Supreme
Guide, stressed that no member of the Brotherhood will
ever sit down with an Israeli.
"I will not allow myself to sit with a criminal. We
will not deal with them in any way."
He added that the Brotherhood may hold a national
referendum to measure public opinion before taking a
final decision about the treaty.
"We will take all the correct legal procedures with
the treaty, it is not biding for me, and the people
will have the final opinion about it.
"We didn't agree to the peace treaty; we will take all
respectable legal procedures towards it. I believe we
have the right to present it to the people and the
elected parliament so that they can come to a decision
about it."
The above words spell resolve but impetuousness as
they reflect the long-suppressed disdain and rejection
among Egyptians of a so-called peace treaty that
enabled Israel to gang on the Palestinians and
arrogated the remainder of their homeland.
In the final analysis, Egypt can and should hold
Israel to account over the clauses of the treaty which
make it an integral part of a wider process which also
includes resolving the Palestinian question in
accordance with UN Security Council 242 and 338.
However, since Israel has violated these resolutions
rather starkly and scandalously, if only by building
hundreds of Jewish colonies on occupied land, and by
transferring hundreds of thousands of its citizens to
live on land that belongs to another people, Egypt
should be able to downgrade its commitment to and
compliance with the infamous treaty to the bare
minimum.
Such a posture on Egypt 's part wouldn't be viewed as
declaration of war or even a unilateral promulgation
of the treaty. It would only be viewed as a necessary
measure reflecting Egypt 's sovereignty and national
will.
There is no doubt that the treaty and relations with
Israel will be a litmus test for the Freedom and
Justice Party (FJP) as well as the other Islamist
party, the Nur, representing the Salafi brothers.
The Islamists under all circumstances must keep a
distance from Israel even if bullied, coerced and
pressured by the United States to behave otherwise.
Any concession, real or imagined, in this regard will
cost the Islamists dearly in terms of their standing
in the eyes of the people.
The Islamists must not allow themselves to gain
acceptance and favor from the criminal entity and her
supporters, especially the Jewish-controlled US
Congress, at the expense of the Egyptian people's
acceptance of the Islamists.
In Egypt as elsewhere in the Arab and Muslim world,
there is a mutually exclusive relationship between
having normal relations with Israel and being accepted
and respected by the masses. A government, including
an Islamist or quasi-Islamist government, can only
have either good relations with Israel and her
supporters on the one hand, or acceptance and respect
from the people, on the other. It can't have both,
period.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments