|
02 March 2012 By Jacob G. Hornberger It's quite amusing to see President Obama,
Secretary of State Clinton, and other U.S. officials
exclaiming against the brutality of the dictatorship
in Syria. One reason, of course, is that the U.S.
government partnered with the Syrian dictatorship
precisely because of its brutality. That's the reason
the CIA, which is a central part of the U.S.
government, delivered Canadian citizen Maher Arar to
Syria to be tortured. U.S. officials knew that the
Syrian dictatorship would do an excellent job of
torturing Arar, which it did for an entire year of the
man's life. There is also the fact that the U.S. government
loves other brutal dictatorships, so long as they are
pro-U.S. Examples include the dictatorships in Egypt,
Jordan, Bahrain, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan
under Musharraf. But there is another reason for amusement: The
dictatorship in Afghanistan, whose primary enforcement
arm is the U.S. military, has been doing the same
thing for years that the Syrian dictatorship has been
doing — killing people who are trying to violently
overthrow the government. In fact, the Syrian dictatorship is doing what
every government in the world, dictatorial or not,
would do to people who were trying to violently
overthrow it. If the U.S. government were faced with
multitudes of citizens who were trying to violently
overthrow the government, make no mistake about it:
the full force of the U.S. government, including the
military, the CIA, and the FBI, would come crashing
down on the rebels, and no options for suppressing
them would be removed from the table. After all, look at what U.S. officials did to Randy
Weaver and his family at Ruby Ridge and to the Branch
Davidians at Waco, and they weren't even trying to
overthrow the government, even though a few paranoid
types might have thought they were. Actually, the
Weavers and the Branch Davidians were simply trying to
be left alone by the government. Nonetheless, the feds
went after them with the same degree of viciousness
and brutality that the Syrian dictatorship is
displaying toward the Syrian rebels. They shot
Weaver's son in the back and his wife in the head,
killing them both. They attacked the Branch Davidian
compound with a military tank (yes, here in the United
States) and injected flammable gas into the building,
knowing that most everyone, including children, would
be killed once it was ignited, which they were. Indeed, consider the War Between the States. The
brutality displayed by the Syrian dictatorship pales
in comparison to what Sherman, Grant, and Lincoln did
to the people of the South. And don't forget that the
Confederates weren't even trying to overthrow the
government, as the Syrian rebels are trying to do.
They were simply trying to secede — leave — the Union.
For that "crime," the U.S. government killed almost
100,000 of them, with another 164,000 dying from
war-related disease and other such things. And let's not forget the Smith Act, which the U.S.
government enacted in 1940. It made it a federal
felony offense to simply advocate the violent
overthrow of the U.S. government. Yes, simple speech
was enough to bring the full force of the federal
government down upon people. More than 200 people were
indicted under the law and countless more learned to
keep their mouths shut. What's the difference between what has been going
on in Afghanistan for the past 10 years and what is
currently going on in Syria? Hasn't the Taliban been
trying to violently overthrow the Karzai regime, after
the U.S. government violently overthrew the Taliban
regime with its military invasion of Afghanistan? And
hasn't the pro-U.S. Karzai regime been killing untold
numbers of insurgents, plus lots of bystanders, for
the past decade for trying to violently overthrow the
government? How is that different from what the Syrian
dictatorship is doing? U.S. officials might respond, "But Afghanistan is a
democracy while Syria isn't." But that's palpable
nonsense. Afghanistan is no more a democracy than
Syria is. After all, didn't they just have an election
in Syria in which constitutional reforms were enacted?
Most everyone would agree that Syrian democracy is a
sham — a rigged game. But how can anyone seriously
argue that it's any different in Afghanistan. The last
presidential election involved countless fraudulent
ballots. What good is a fraudulent election? It is
equivalent to no election at all, which makes the
Afghan government as illegitimate as the Syrian
regime. Moreover, simply because a regime is democratically
elected doesn't mean it's not a dictatorship. The
U.S.-supported regime in Afghanistan has all the
dictatorial powers that the Syrian dictatorship has:
the power to round people up without warrants, detain
them indefinitely without trial, torture them, and
execute them, just as the Syrian regime does. With the U.S. military serving as its primary
enforcement force, the Afghan regime exercises its
dictatorial powers to the full extent. It is
impossible to know how many people it has killed,
detained, tortured, maimed, executed, and assassinated
during the past 10 years, but the number is far in
excess of the number killed by the Syrian regime. What should the U.S. government do about the
situation in Syria? It should butt out of the Syrian
conflict. Syria belongs to the Syrians, not to the
U.S. government. For that matter, the U.S. government should also
butt out of Afghanistan. If the crooked, corrupt,
fraudulent, illegitimate Karzai regime cannot stand on
its own after ten years, that's its problem. The U.S.
government needs to immediately stop serving as the
enforcement agency of the Karzai dictatorship and
immediately withdraw from Afghanistan. It's time for
the U.S. government to stop its hypocritical preaching
and lead by example. Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of the
Future of Freedom Foundation. |