|
18 March 2012 By Jacob G. Hornberger In an era of unrestrained federal spending and
debt, one of the most ludicrous arguments made by
statists is that reducing the military budget would be
harmful to the economy. Their suggestion is that
military spending is beneficial to the economy — that
it creates jobs. Reducing military spending, they say,
would result in laying off troops and downsizing of
firms that supply uniforms, guns, etc. to the
military. Like I say, that is an absolutely ludicrous
argument. In fact, the Castro regime in Cuba is faced with
much the same situation. In that country, the
government employs not just the military but also
everyone else in society. Not long ago, the government
proposed laying off 500,000 government employees.
Undoubtedly, Cuban statist economists said the same
thing about that proposal that American statists say
about reducing U.S. military spending — that it would
increase the unemployment rate and hurt the Cuban
economy, where everyone is on the verge of starvation.
Let's assume that we lived in a society in which
there was no income tax, one in which people kept
everything they earned. Let's also assume that 99
percent of the populace is employed in the private
sector. That means that most everyone in society is in the
productive sector — that is, the sector that is
producing goods and services for everyone in society.
That's one of the main reasons that everyone's
standard of living in that society is rising. One day, the federal government announces that it
has selected 25 percent of the population to be in a
privileged class of people who no longer have to work.
From that point on, the government levies a 25 percent
tax on those who are still in the private sector and
gives the money to those in the privileged class. Notice that there is a doubly negative effect in
this scenario. One negative effect is that the
productive sector has been reduced by 25 percent. With
less people producing goods and services, everyone's
standard of living grows more slowly. The other
negative effect is that 25 percent of the income of
those still in the private sector is taken away from
them — income that could have gone into capital (e.g.,
tools and equipment) that would have made people even
more productive. That's effectively what the federal government has
done with its ever-growing massive military machine
that was left in existence after World War II. The
federal government drew a large number of people out
of the private sector and into the public sector, and
it has used the money seized from the people left in
the private sector to fund them. One possible response is that the military machine
was necessary to keep us safe. That's a separate issue
and highly disputed by libertarians. But simply
because it's necessary from a military standpoint
doesn't make it beneficial from an economic
standpoint. The fact remains that an enormous military
machine — just like any other enormous government
bureaucracy — is an horrible parasitic drain on the
economic well-being of a nation. Consider how extensive the military-industrial
complex has become in American life. One of the most
ingenious strategies employed by the complex is
spreading its military projects through congressional
districts all across America. In that way, communities
all across the land can be threatened with a loss of
their projects (i.e., jobs) in the face of military
cutbacks. You've also got the domestic-base syndrome.
Communities that have a nearby military base have
conniption fits whenever anyone suggests that the base
be closed. And then there are the countless suppliers to the
military of such things as bombs, bullets, planes,
drones, tanks, uniforms, coffee, meals, medals, and so
forth. Whenever one proposes cuts in military spending,
everyone who has become dependent on the largess goes
into action by calling on their congressmen to stop
the proposed reductions, at least insofar as they
affect their particular area. Of course, they always couch their argument in
terms of the public interest, not their own parasitic
dependencies. They cry, "This is no time to make such
reductions. We need more federal spending and debt,
not less. If we cut back now, it will mean layoffs,
both among the troops and the suppliers. That would
hurt the economy." But let's work backwards to show how fallacious
that argument is. Suppose that the government lays off the 25 percent
that are in the military sector, sending them into the
private sector. The result of that scenario will be doubly positive
for two reasons: One, those people will now be in the private sector
— that is, the productive sector. They will now be
producing goods and services for everyone in society,
thereby contributing to people's standard of living.
Two, people will no longer have 25 percent of their
income taken away from them to fund the military. That
25 percent can be added to the pool of capital, making
people more productive, causing standards of living to
rise. Reflect again on the Cuban situation. What would be
the ideal solution for Cuba, where the state employs
most everyone? It should immediately lay off millions
of people in the public sector, sending them into the
private sector. Overnight, there would be tremendous
economic vitality, as people move toward opening
businesses or going to work for new businesses. Over
time, the overall standard of living of the Cuban
people would soar. The same principle applies to the public sector
here in the United States. The best thing Americans
could ever do, from an economic standpoint, is to
immediately dismantle the federal government's
welfare-state programs and bureaucracy and its
warfare-state, imperialist programs and bureaucracy
and eliminate the taxes that fund them. That's the key
to economic well-being and to ever-increasing
standards of living. Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of the
Future of Freedom Foundation. |