|
23 March 2012 By Juan Cole JihadWatch's anti-Muslim fear-mongering
director Robert Spencer likes to selectively highlight
the most egregious and sectarian statements by Muslims
to further his hate agenda against Islam/Muslims. In the wake of the death of the Coptic Pope
Shenouda III he posted a piece about how a
cleric named Wagdi Ghoneim said that
the death of Pope Shenouda was a "relief" because the
Pope caused "sectarian strife" and sought to make
Egypt into a "Coptic state." To address that specifically, I wonder if the irony
is lost on Wagdi Ghoneim, he accused Pope Shenouda of
having furthered "sectarian strife" but by writing
what he did he himself engaged in "sectarian strife." While there are small fringe groups of Copts who
wish to turn Egypt into a Coptic state, trying to push
this concept as emerging from the Pope, or the
mainstream of Copts is similar to the "Islamization"
myth that ironically Spencer and his acolytes regularly engage
in. The Pope himself was a nationalist and opposed
"foreign intervention" and stated that while Copts are
"marginalized" in Egypt they are not "oppressed." That said, the main point I want to highlight is
the fact that Robert Spencer is attempting to shift
focus from the overwhelming support and expressions of
condolences and grief from Muslims for the passing of
the Pope. He chooses one cleric and tries to attribute
it as the general feeling of Muslim Egyptians. This couldn't be further from the truth. High ranking Muslim politicians, scholars, clerics,
intellectuals and lay people expressed their sympathy
and sadness at his passing. "His holiness lived and died as a loyal patriot
to his country," Parliament Speaker Saad el-Katatni,
an Islamist, told a joint meeting of the two
chambers of parliament Saturday. Sheikh Ahmed El-Tayeb, Grand Imam
of al-Azhar, the highest seat of religious learning in
the Sunni world, offered his condolences to the
Egyptian people for such a great loss, saying, "Egypt has lost one of its rare men at a
sensitive moment when it most needs the wisest of
its wise – their expertise and their purity of
minds." Egypt Mufti Sheikh Ali Gomaa also
mourned the deceased pontiff as a great Egyptian and
patriot, saying, "His death is a tragedy and a great loss for
Egypt and its people of Muslims and Christians." Freedom and Justice Party, the Muslim Brotherhood's
political arm and the party with the largest majority
in parliament stated, "The Freedom and Justice Party sends its deepest
condolences to the Egyptian people and our Christian
brothers over the death of Pope Shenouda III," FJP
leader Mohamed Mursi said. Presidential contenders such as Amr Moussa and
Ahmed Shafiq also expressed their sadness, Presidential aspirant Amr Moussa said he was
saddened by Pope Shenouda's death. "We have lost a great value and a pre-eminent
pope," said Ahmed Shafiq, another presidential
contender, and a Mubarak-era prime minister. For more see: Egypt Muslims Mourn Pope Shenouda's
Passing Here is a picture of Egyptian Christians
expressing their thanks and reciprocating the "love"
they received at the death of their leader: Egyptian Christians stand in front of a picture of
the late Pope Shenouda III after receiving condolences
from both Muslims and Christians. Signs read in Arabic
(H/T: ZH): "We feel your love. Thank you, Muslim
brothers and sisters" |