Why This Absurdity? Why Hezbollah, The
Huthis, al-Assad And Others In The Region
28 March 2012
By Tariq Alhomayed
Everybody who is monitoring our region, particularly
after the so-called "Arab Spring", will find
themselves facing a pressing question, namely: why
have we wasted our time, capabilities and
opportunities – over decades – and remained in the
same state, namely a state of regression, or shall we
say backwardness?
In order to clarify the picture, let us look at a
group of disconnected news items in order to clear up
the situation in our region. A few weeks ago, Mr.
Rashid Ghannouchi announced that secularism is not
contrary to Islam, whilst 9 years after his arrest,
the Iraqi government announced the acquittal of the
former Iraqi Minister of Trade under Saddam Hussein
and released him. Also this week, Egypt announced the
acquittal of the brother of Al Qaeda leader Ayman al-Zawahiri,
years after his arrest, whilst the Egyptian Muslim
Brotherhood and the Salafist al-Nour party, expressed
their condolences to Egypt's Coptic community over the
death of Pope Shenouda III. The question here is: why
have we wasted decades of opportunities, when the
situation in our region was not correct or accurate,
whether on the level of individuals, groups or states,
whilst today we are dealing with all of these issues
easily?
Why did Ghannouchi spend years fighting in opposition
to the Tunisian regime whilst today he is utilizing
the same logic as Bourguiba, may he rest in peace?
What would have happened if the "civilized" Ghannouchi
had worked to build Bourguiba's Tunisia more than two
decades ago or more? If he had done this, what state
would Tunisia be in today? Why did Iraq delay the
release of an innocent man who was only charged nine
years after his arrest? What would have happened if
the Iraqis had sat down for genuine reconciliation,
and did not carry out the criminal Debaathificiation
process? In this case, what state would Iraq be in
today? What if the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, as
well as the Salafists, gave the Copts their rights and
proceeded to draft a new constitution based on the
concept of citizenship, not religion, and understood
that the homeland is for all, and that religion is for
God to decide, so long as they are now offering
condolences on the death of Pope Shenouda III? In
which case, what state would Egypt be in today? Or is
the issuance of condolences on the death of Pope
Shenouda III a public relations campaign and nothing
more? What if the Mubarak regime had operated under
the principle that no bearer of burdens shall bear the
burden of another, with regards to the case of Ayman
al-Zawahiri's brother? In which case, would Mubarak's
end have been the same?
Here one might say "ifs" do not benefit anybody,
however this is one of the tragedies of Arab culture,
for this does not mean wishful thinking, so much as it
means learning from lessons, studying past mistakes
and ensuring these are not repeated. We were deceived,
for example, by the Muslim Brotherhood with regards to
the issue of peace with Israel, however the Muslim
Brotherhood are now ruling Egypt which continues to
have ongoing relations with Israel, at the same time
that the al-Assad regime is committing crimes against
the Syrian people which are far worse than any crimes
committed by the Israelis against us! All of this is
happening because we failed to read modern history
correctly, and we did not learn from our past
mistakes, and we did not ask one simple question,
namely: what has been achieved for the Arab people in
our region?
So when Ghannouchi says that certain parties, by which
he means the Salafists, will one day reach awareness
and rationality, as he – in his own opinion – has
today, we must ask ourselves: why aren't the
rabble-rousers or the impetuous leading the political
and cultural scene in the west, as they do in our
region?
This is a question that requires more discussion, in
order to understand why we have Hamas, Hezbollah, the
Huthis, al-Assad and others, in our region.
Tariq Alhomayed is the Editor-in-Chief of Asharq
Al-Awsat, the youngest person to be appointed that
position. He holds a BA degree in Media studies from
King Abdul Aziz University in Jeddah, and has also
completed his Introductory courses towards a Master's
degree from George Washington University in Washington
D.C. He is based in London.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments