|
15 June 2012
By Jacob G. Hornberger This week, the Egyptian people got a taste of the
reality of military dictatorship, while the American
people got a taste of the reality of U.S. foreign
policy. The Egyptian Supreme Court dissolved the Egyptian
Parliament, and Egypt's military dictatorship declared
martial law in the country. These dictatorial events
occurred just a few days before Egypt's presidential
run-off election. Even though a president is being elected, there
still is no constitution in place. That means that
whoever is elected president will have omnipotent
dictatorial powers, given that there will be no
constitution to limit his powers and no Parliament to
oppose his exercise of power. Of course, the newly elected president will have to
answer to the Egyptian military, which ultimately
remains in charge. Thus, the real issue in Egypt is that the country
is governed by a military dictatorship, one that has
made it very clear that it does not intend to
relinquish or subordinate its power to anyone or any
institution. As long as the military dictatorship remains in
control of the country, everything else, including the
Parliament and the presidency, is just
window-dressing. And make no mistake about it: military dictatorship
equals tyranny. For decades, the Egyptian people have
been suffering under a brutal tyranny. As long as the
military remains in control of the country, the
Egyptian people will continue to suffer under that
brutal tyranny. Any hope of achieving a free society
under a military dictatorship is delusionary. Some Egyptians figured that the solution to their
woes lay simply in getting rid of the longtime head of
the dictatorship, Hosni Mubarak. The Egyptian military
itself was obviously hoping that the citizenry would
be satisfied with Mubarak's ouster. But the core problem was never Mubarak. The core
problem was — and remains — Egypt's military
dictatorship, which, like America's national-security
state, is deeply imbedded in the country's societal
and economic affairs. What will happen with respect to the Parliament and
the presidential election? Whatever the military
dictatorship allows to happen. The military
dictatorship is in charge. If Egyptians want a genuinely free society, the
only way to achieve that is by making the military
subordinate to civilian institutions and by
dismantling its omnipotent role and power in Egyptian
society. If the military doesn't go along with that —
and every indication is that it won't — that leaves
the citizenry with a difficult choice: whether to
resort to violence in an attempt to oust the
dictatorship by force, as citizens in Syria are doing,
or whether to simply accept their lot in life under
military dictatorship. Meanwhile, American taxpayers recently sent their
annual contribution of $1.2 billion, through the U.S.
government's foreign aid program, to the Egyptian
military dictatorship. That money is being used by the
dictatorship to purchase things like guns, tanks,
planes, and other instruments of war from U.S. arms
suppliers, which will, needless to say, be employed
against any Egyptian citizens who try to violently
overthrow their country's military dictatorship. And this isn't the first time that the U.S.
government has funded Egypt's military dictatorship.
The U.S. government has been sending billions of
dollars to the dictatorship for decades with the full
knowledge of the horrible oppression it was inflicting
on the Egyptian people. The U.S. government's notion has always coincided
with that of the Egyptian dictatorship: that it was
vitally important to maintain "order and stability"
within Egypt, which is why U.S. officials not only
funded the dictatorship but also ensured that Egyptian
troops received training from the U.S. military. Throughout all the years that U.S. officials were
funding Egypt's military dictatorship, they didn't see
anything wrong with the dictatorship. On the contrary,
they believed in it, they embraced it, and they
supported it. And they still do. Thus, it was no surprise when the world learned
that the U.S. government had made the Egyptian
military dictatorship one of its rendition-torture
partners in the "war on terrorism." What will happen if Egyptian citizens resort to
violence to bring an end to tyranny in their country?
Who knows? It's impossible to predict the outcome. But
two things are for sure: The Egyptian military
dictatorship will be using weaponry provided by the
U.S. government in an attempt to quell the rebellion.
Moreover, there will be undoubtedly many U.S.
officials who will be cheering the efforts of their
counterparts within Egypt's military dictatorship to
restore "order and stability" to the country. Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of the
Future of Freedom Foundation. |