A War of Sectarians, Not a Sectarian War: Shirazi, Like Khamenei, Political Not Religious
25 July 2014
By Amir Taheri
The current crisis in Iraq is routinely described by
international media as a "sectarian" war. The
assumption is that Iraq is being torn apart because
its various component parts, especially Arab Sunnis
and Shi'ites, have somehow decided they can no longer
live together.
How accurate is that analysis? The answer to that
question could have a major impact on shaping the
outcome of the crisis. Some of those who claim that
Iraqis can no longer live together insist that the
frontiers drawn after the collapse of the Ottoman
Empire are no longer valid and that new frontiers
should be envisaged for newly emerging nation-states.
At the heart of such analyses is the claim that Iraq
is an "artificial country" that was unsustainable from
the start. Once, on a BBC television program, I was
bitterly attacked by an American university professor
because I had suggested that the US should have
remained by Iraq's side for a few more years, as had
been the case with West Germany after the Second World
War, to help the Iraqis consolidate their new
institutions.
Adopting a mocking tone, the professor shot back that,
being a new state with no democratic experience, Iraq
could not be compared to Germany, which had a long
history and much experience of democracy.
Apparently, our professor did not know that Iraq has a
history dating back at least 4,000 years, long before
the first Germanic tribes appeared in Europe. Nor did
he know that Germany became a nation-state in 1870.
Modern Iraq attained the same status in 1921. With an
interval of half a century—a mere flash in the
saucepan of history—both Germany and modern Iraq
emerged from the debris of empires.
As for "democratic experience," neither Germany's
tragedy under Nazism nor Iraq under Ba'athism amounted
to "democratic experience." Under its monarchy, Iraq
enjoyed as much freedom as various components of the
future German state had done under their respective
princes.
The subtext of my American detractor's claim is that
Iraqis, being Arabs or Muslims, are incapable of
living in freedom. Arabs and Muslims, in his view, are
generally genetically programed to favor despotic
rule. If Iraq's "newness" and "artificiality" means it
has no right to be a united modern nation-state, why
not apply the same rule to the 158 members of the
United Nations that are newer and more artificial than
Iraq? With that yardstick, every single country in the
world could be divided into its parts and every
frontier redrawn. Believe it or not, Iraq in its
present form is one of the three oldest modern Arab
states.
There are, of course, several powers and a few
elements inside Iraq itself with a vested interest in
seeing the country dismembered. Dismantling Iraq might
suit the strategies of those powers and elements, but
it will be no solution to the current crisis, which is
rooted elsewhere.
The current crisis could best be described as a war of
the sectarians, rather than a sectarian war. The mass
of Iraq's Sunnis and Shi'ites are not involved in this
conflict except as victims. The fact that sectarian
factions on both sides use a theological vocabulary
should not mislead us. The reason is that Islamic
languages, notably Arabic, lack a secular political
vocabulary. That has been manifest throughout Islamic
history. The first civil war in Islam, between Ali Ibn
Abi Taleb and Muawiyah I, had nothing to do with rival
interpretations of the faith. It was about political
power and was caused by rival claims to rulership.
Nevertheless, the only way that rivalry could be
expressed at the time was through a theological
lexicon, which, in turn and over several centuries,
encouraged the concoction of a doctrinal schism.
Today in Iraq, Prime Minister Nuri Al-Maliki wishes to
hang on to power as long as he can. This has nothing
to do with his being a Shi'ite. Saddam Hussein,
supposedly a Sunni, had a similar attitude to the
bitter end. The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS)
and its allies who are wreaking havoc in Iraq are also
motivated by a thirst for power, rather than any
concern about a specific interpretation of the faith.
They fight for political objectives disguised as
religious aims.
That is underlined by the fact that no credible
theologian on either side has provided a religious
cover for the struggle. On the Sunni side, almost all
bona fide theologians have appealed for peace and
reconciliation. On the Shi'ite side, too, the
overwhelming tone of the senior clergy has been in
favor of calming things down. Despite a string of
political pressure, senior clerics such as Grand
Ayatollah Ali Al-Sistani in Najaf and Grand Ayatollah
Alawi Borujerdi in Qom in Iran have refused to declare
jihad against ISIS. In Qom, only one Ayatollah,
Makarem Shirazi, has used the term "jihad," indicating
his ignorance of the principles and rules under which
such a call is made. However, Shirazi, like Iran's
Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, is a political rather
than religious figure, and thus cannot pretend to
express a theological position.
As Borujerdi has declared in a fatwa, regardless of
sectarian backgrounds, Iraqis should fight in
self-defense in support of the country's regular armed
forces against those who wish to dismember their
state. Thus, the current conflict should not be sued
by such adventurers as Moqtada Al-Sadr to revive their
militias and push Iraq back to the bad old days of
terror in the name of faith.
Others, including some Kurds who muse about secession,
hoping to fish in muddy waters by advancing their
political pawns, should also be warned that they could
end up among the losers.
Iraq can and must weather its latest storm. And it is
in everyone's best interest that it does so with its
sovereignty and territorial integrity intact.
Amir Taheri was born in Ahvaz, southwest Iran, and
educated in Tehran, London and Paris. He was Executive
Editor-in-Chief of the daily Kayhan in Iran (1972-79).
In 1980-84, he was Middle East Editor for the Sunday
Times. In 1984-92, he served as member of the
Executive Board of the International Press Institute (IPI).
Between 1980 and 2004, he was a contributor to the
International Herald Tribune. He has written for the
Wall Street Journal, the New York Post, the New York
Times, the London Times, the French magazine Politique
Internationale, and the German weekly Focus. Between
1989 and 2005, he was editorial writer for the German
daily Die Welt. Taheri has published 11 books, some of
which have been translated into 20 languages. He has
been a columnist for Asharq Alawsat since 1987.
Taheri's latest book "The Persian Night" is published
by Encounter Books in London and New York.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments