Abbas' Dismal Failure At The United Nations: His Last Opportunity—One He Cannot Afford To Miss
01 October 2014
By Alon Ben-Meir
As someone who has consistently advocated a peace
agreement between Israel and the Palestinians based on
a two-state solution, I was appalled to hear the
speech delivered by Palestinian Authority President
Mahmoud Abbas at the United Nations General Assembly.
Instead of using the occasion to provide constructive
proposals and use reconciliatory language to advance
the cause of peace, he engaged in acrimonious and
discordant statements against Israel that did nothing
but further embitter and alienate the Israeli public,
whose support he needs the most to realize Palestinian
aspirations.
I wonder if Abbas has any clue how his irresponsible
public utterances reinforce the negative perceptions
between the Israelis and Palestinians and perpetuate
the endemic hostility which has and remains the core
evil that has thwarted all peace efforts in the past.
He gave a campaign-style speech, appealing to his own
public in an effort to salvage his sagging popularity,
while being completely oblivious to the fact that he
was addressing the international community to further
cement its support of the Palestinian cause.
To be sure, as the late Israeli Foreign Minister Abba
Eban once said, "The Arabs [Palestinians] never miss
an opportunity to miss an opportunity." Abbas'
performance was a classic case of a missed
opportunity.
His failure to strike a balance between his
justifiable resistance to the occupation and the need
to rally the support of the Israeli public was a major
blunder, deeply injurious to the Palestinian cause.
For someone who seems genuine in seeking peace, he
shattered the trust of many Israelis, who view him as
a reliable partner that deserves their support.
In his polarizing speech, Abbas spared no deprecating
characterization of Israel, the very country with
which he must negotiate to end the occupation and
establish a Palestinian state—a dim prospect made
dimmer by his desperate need to maintain his position.
He accused Israel of committing genocide three times,
a horrifying term that enraged every Israeli. They
know the real meaning of genocide, when the Jews were
led like sheep to the slaughter. They also know that
their army took every precaution to protect the lives
of innocent Palestinian civilians during the Israel-Hamas
war.
Abbas invoked the word Nakba (the "catastrophe" of
1948) five times, which does nothing but enflame
emotional outbursts anew, making it ever more
difficult for him to make and for the Palestinians to
accept any concessions to facilitate a peace agreement
with Israel.
In his wisdom, he referred to Israel as a racist state
seven times without thinking that such maligning
attribution only undermines the negotiating process
and intensifies the distrust, which will make the
conflict ever more intractable.
He recklessly used the word fascist twice, but however
cruel the Israeli occupation may be, ascribing such a
revolting word reminds the Israelis of their own
victimhood, which hardens rather than lessens their
antagonism and enmity toward the Palestinians.
As if the above charges are insufficient to paint the
"true face" of Israel, Abbas throws in, for good
measure, another vile characterization of Israel as an
apartheid state twice and as a terrorist state, well,
only once.
President Abbas strongly denounced Israel's massive
air attacks against Gaza, but did not even allude to
the nearly 4,000 rockets fired indiscriminately by
Hamas at Israel's urban centers including Tel Aviv and
Jerusalem.
Abbas rightfully condemned the abduction of a young
Palestinian boy, Mohammed Abu Khdeir, who was
gruesomely burned alive, but conveniently forgot the
kidnapping and summary execution of three Israeli
teenagers by Hamas' operatives—Naftali Fraenkel, Gilad
Shaer and Eyal Yifran—which precipitated the latest
Israel-Hamas war.
I am not a great fan of Prime Minister Netanyahu and
have for years been critical of his policy toward the
Palestinians. However, in his speech at the UNGA, he
rose above the fray and conveyed a message that
resonated even among the Arab states' representatives
as he likened Hamas to ISIS.
Netanyahu emphasized the danger of militant Islamists
to the Arab states and skillfully pointed out that
Shiite Iran is a threat not only to Israel but also to
the Sunni Arab states. He drew a glaring common cause
to which every Arab state could subscribe.
Instead of engaging in a tit-for-tat with Abbas,
Netanyahu did not even once criticize the Palestinian
Authority, but rather singled out Hamas who instigated
the last war that led to the death of nearly 2,100
Palestinians and massive destruction throughout Gaza.
Netanyahu clung to the larger regional picture and
made a strong case that the regional challenges can be
met when Israel and the Arab states are at peace,
which will facilitate and usher in peace between
Israel and the Palestinians.
As I read and reread Abbas' speech, I wondered who the
advisors are that recommended he go on a tirade
against Israel in front of the international community
instead of putting forth constructive and credible
plans that would advance the Palestinian quest for a
state of their own.
Demanding an end to the occupation within an
unspecified period is not a plan; to threaten to turn
to the International Criminal Court is not a plan; to
join Hamas without insisting that it renounce violence
is not a plan.
Instead, he should have started by seeking the support
of the international community to resettle the
Palestinian refugees in the West Bank and Gaza,
instead of continuously using them as political pawns
for seven decades.
For Abbas to fall into the trap that Hamas carefully
dug for him suggests only one thing: squeezed between
Israel and Hamas, Abbas lost his bearings. He knows
only too well that Hamas seeks his political demise
and instead of calling a spade a spade, he succumbed
to the bitter reality of Palestinian factionalism and
Hamas' whims.
The Palestinians have no leaders with vision and
courage, leaders who can change the political
discourse and abandon the old narrative of hatred and
animosity toward Israel and the empty slogans that
have long since lost any meaning and only poison
another generation of Palestinians.
That said, Abbas can still play an important role in
the upcoming indirect Israeli-Hamas negotiations in
Cairo. He may now have one more chance to assert his
leadership. He can do so by insisting that the
Palestinian Authority take real charge over the
security in Gaza, which in any case both Egypt and
Israel insist upon.
He must also make it abundantly clear to Hamas that
the PA will not come to its aid under the false
pretenses of a unity government unless Hamas cease and
desist from provoking Israel and gradually
demilitarize Gaza; otherwise, no power can force
Israel to lift the blockade.
The Arab states and especially Egypt, who quietly
hailed Israel's inflicting such a punishing blow on
Hamas, are as eager as Israel to emasculate Hamas.
Unfortunately, there is only a small chance that the
negotiations in Egypt could lead to such an outcome.
But then, this is the only outcome that can save Abbas
politically and spare the Palestinians in Gaza from
another disastrous confrontation with Israel.
This may well be his last opportunity—one he cannot
afford to miss.
©
EsinIslam.Com
Add Comments